Creating a cultural space
Reviewed by Maria Aslam
2025-01-19
Some books shape your very essence, cultivating your perspective, challenging your comfort, and becoming an inseparable part of your journey. The book Documenting the National Art Gallery, Pakistan is one such story of an architect`s project that is inseparable from his life`s journey.
This book chronicles the dream and relentless passion of an architect, designer and artist whose life`s work finds its ultimate expression in a singular project,envisioned as a testament to the extra ordinary brilliance of Pakistan`s creative industry. It tells the story of a venture that simultaneously became his nemesis and his magnum opus, encapsulating both his professional triumphs and personal trials.
Beyond its architectural significance, the book delves into a narrative of perseverance, resilience, and vision qualities that resonate deeply within Pakistan`s history.
At its heart is author Naeem Pasha, an architect by profession and a dreamer by habit. Through this book, his journey emerges not just as a testament to his exceptional architectural craft but also as a tribute to his unwavering dedication to an idea larger than himself. His story exemplifies how a singular vision, pursued with determination, can create an enduring impact one that honours both the art and the soul of a nation.
The making of the book was itself a journey, culminating in 2024 though it chronicles the evolution of a landmark project that was completed in 2007. The National Art Gallery (NAG) is a testament to the passage of time, perseverance and the intricate dynamics of public works, the very first national gallery in Pakistan after seven decades of independence. This prolonged timeline encapsulates the lack of vision and shifting political landscapes that mark Pakistan`s history. It is a narrative deeply intertwined with the challenges of governance and planning, and the bureaucratic inertia that often accompanies projects in the Global South.
While much has been written about the history and advancement of the project, what remains insufficiently emphasised is the story of the author himself, who championed this vision. Against the backdrop of bureaucratic indifference and the often impersonal, cold administrative environments of the new capital, Islamabad, the architect displayed unwavering dedication. The resolve to see the project through, despite countless delays, policy shifts and political upheavals, underscores the transformative power of determination.
The project`s journey was shaped not only by the complexities of architectural practice but also by the socio-political realities of Pakistan. From the original design competition in 1989 to eventual completion in 2007, every phase reflects the evolving aspirations of a nation seeking to preserve and celebrate its artistic and cultural identity. The architect`s refusal to abandon a project rooted in the arts and intended for the enrichment of the masses stands as a powerful reminder of the human spirit`s resilience. This vision and tenacity ensured that the gallery would become a beacon of creativity, a symbol of hope, and a testament to the importance of cultural infrastructure.
The book is a composite of three main parts. The inaugural opening show in 2007 in the eight galleries of NAG is splashed in the opening of the book.
The inaugural show, comprising highly acclaimed curators and participating artists, was almost akin to the biennials that captivate the artistic audiences of Karachi and Lahore in today`s time. The show attempted to encapsulate the art spectrum of the country for the very first time under one roof. A review of the show and the copious artwork is not the mandate of the current review. However, it goes without saying that a separate publication can be engineered of the expansive Pakistan artistic oeuvre that was spread between the ten exhibitions.
The second part of Documenting the National Art Gallery delves into the inauguration of the project in Islamabad, charting the challenging journey that ultimately led to its current location. It narrates the evolving design briefs shaped within the corridors of power, the ambiguous understanding by governing bodies of the need for a permanent gallery space for Pakistani art, and how, during Gen Musharraf`s tenure, `curiosity about the unfinished National Art Gallery propelled its completion.
The story is also a reflection of the architect`s ability to mediate between the complexities of service and what it serves. The sequence of events leading to the gallery`s creation underscores the architect`s skill in resolving the dichotomy between functionality and the symbolic, elevating the gallery into an enduring icon. Through its design, the building transcends mere utility to become a powerful expression of Pakistan`s artistic and cultural aspirations.
Architect and conservationist Masood Ahmed Khan, in the third part of the book, offers fascinating insights into the design journey of NAG. He reveals that Naeem Pasha`s architectural firm secured the project through a competitive design process in 1989, outshining renowned architects Habib Fida Ali and Nayyar Ali Dada, who were declared runnersup. Notably, the winning design was initially conceived for a site that is now home to the Prime Minister`s Office complex on Constitution Avenue in Islamabad, adding a layer of historical intrigue to the gallery`s evolution.
A pivotal aspect of the book is its focus on the drawings and the meticulous process involved in bringing NAG to life. Created during an era when hand-drafted designs were the norm, the project stands as a testament to the art of architectural craftsmanship. The gallery`s creation is marked by hundreds of composite drawings, each reflecting the depth of thought, precision and creativity that culminated in this architectural masterpiece.
These drawings not only document the journey of the gallery but also serve as a window into a time when architecture was as much about artistry as it was about structure. This creative journey was marked by a wealth of working sketches, precise measured drawings, mechanical renderings, and intricately coloured views. Each iteration contributed to refining the vision, ensuring that every detail aligned with the gallery`s purpose and architectural aspirations.
The book further sheds light on a noteworthy moment in the gallery`s history: a proposed relocation to F-9 Park in 1995. This proposal highlights the profound impact that a change in context can have on architectural decisions, influencing materials, layout and design details,even when the fundamental purpose of the structure remains unchanged.
The evolution of the gallery`s design underscores the dynamic relationship between a building`s function and its environment, showcasing the adaptability and ingenuity integral to thoughtful architectural practice.
Situated among Islamabad`s monumental buildings of authority, the poised grandeur of NAG`s imposing façade stands as a testament to its cultural and architectural significance.
It commands attention not just through its presence, but through the depth of its design language and the narrative it embodies.
In the grand launch of the book in Karachi, Pasha hoped a project of such profound relevance and architectural distinction would inspire future doctoral and masters students to explore the myriad dimensions it offers. NAG, with its carefully considered design and cultural significance, stands as an emblem of how architecture can engage with art and society, creating fertile ground for scholarly inquiry.
The building`s layered narrative opens numerous threads of academic exploration. From its architectural evolution and design philosophy to its role in shaping cultural identity and fostering artistic expression, the gallery is a repository of rich research possibilities. It embodies the intersections of art, society, politics and urban planning, each offering a potential avenue for deeper investigation.
Pasha`s vision extended beyond the physical structure; he saw the gallery as a catalyst for intellectual and artistic growth. The research journey initiated with the conception of NAG is far from over it lays the foundation for an ongoing dialogue that can inspire generations of scholars to examine the finer nuances of art and architecture, and their placement within society.
The reviewer is a writer, architectural historian and environmental activist. She is also the founding editor of ADA Magazine