Page 28 · Business & Finance

Winners and losers

The sugarcane harvesting season has arrived but farmers are increasingly worried.

In the past, provincial governments determined the minimum cane prices and announced the start of the crushing season. However, in 2024-25, the government deregulated the sugar sector under conditions agreed with the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Unfortunately, deregulation has not extended across the entire value chain.

Instead, it has largely freed sugar mills to procure sugarcane from farmers without a regulated minimum price, while sugar prices and import-export decisions remain subject to government control. Under this arrangement, farmers are emerging as the biggest losers, particularly as increased acreage and expected higher yields point to a bumper crop ready for harvest.

Sugarcane farmers have not faced such a major policy setback since the 1970s. Under the Punjab Sugarcane Control Order, 1972, farmers were restricted from manufacturing ‘gur’ (jaggery) in areas reserved for specific sugar mills. The zoning system also bound them to sell their sugarcane only to the mill designated for their area. These restrictions, which remained in force until 1987, were part of the government’s efforts to establish the sugar industry, seemingly at farmers’ expense.

Similarly, current deregulation of sugarcane prices appears to be an effort to align the sector with global markets, without providing export subsidies to millers. This is particularly important because sugarcane production has reached a level at which Pakistan produces a surplus, making exports essential. However, this approach does little to protect farmers, or ensure them a fair return, even as they struggle with rising input costs, including diesel, electricity, fertilisers, and pesticides.

Farmers do not expect a fair deal from millers following deregulation, particularly as sugarcane production and thus supply has increased substantially because farmers have limited alternative crop choices. They argue that the current price of aroundRs400-450 per 40kg does not even cover current production costs.

Another concern among farmers is the delay in announcing crushing dates. Farmers allege that millers deliberately delay crushing because late harvesting improves sugar recovery and increases millers’ profits, even though it reduces farmers’ sugarcane weight. Such delays also disrupt farmers’ crop-planning cycles, particularly for those intending to sow wheat after harvesting sugarcane.

Millers, on the other hand, publicly argue that they have surplus sugar stocks of around one million tonnes and that the government failed to make a timely decision on exports.

Consequently, they face liquidity constraints and a shortage of warehouse space, leaving them with little choice but to delay the crushing.

In fact, the government has failed to balance its competing policy imperatives: keeping domestic sugar prices at or below international market levels while ensuring farmers receive a fair return to sustain sugarcane cultivation.

Instead, the government appears to have prioritised the interests of consumers and millers, leaving growers to bear the brunt of this policy shift.

In defence of deregulation, policymakers frequently cite the rice sector as a successful example of a market where prices are determined by supply and demand. However, the two sectors have fundamentally different market structures, making such a comparison misleading.

Sugar deregulation has resulted in distributive inequity, with millers benefiting at the expense of farmers. This is largely because the government has neither created competitive market conditions nor put effective regulatory safeguards in place. The Competition Commission of Pakistan, meanwhile, has proved ineffective in ensuring fair market competition.

The government must, therefore, revisit its deregulation policy.

Otherwise, as seen in the wheat sector, farmers may have little choice but to reduce acreage, potentially turning the country from a sugar-surplus nation into a net importer. •