I HAPPENED to catch an Indian film on Netflix this week, Daayra. And for some reason, it stayed with me so much that I would rather write about it this week than any of the more important topics such as soobay, local governments, kruption and the various political statements on each of these issues.
The film caught my eye because it starred Kareena Kapoor in a non-glam role, which in itself should have sent off alarm bells. The last such film she did was also rather meh but then film watching is generally a case of hope over experience. Or simply just boredom when it comes to streaming platforms.
This too appeared to be an OTT release and revolved around police encounters; the second reason for my interest. After all, it’s an issue that has garnered much attention these days in Pakistan.
The film revolves around a brutal gang rape and murder of a young woman and the police on the hunt for the accused. Once they are caught, the police team sent to catch them take a quick decision to kill them all in an encounter. And the encounter leads to what appears to be nationwide celebrations by ordinary people. The police officer who led the chase and the encounter becomes a celebrity who is asked for ‘selfies’ and why not, for his biceps are just as impressive and just as tightly clad as those of the spies in Dharundar.
But despite the celebratory mood, some human rights organisations file petitions compelling the police to send an internal team to investigate the incident. Enter Kapoor and her band of policewallahs. The rest of the film provides two parallel accounts of the rape and its investigation by the police team and the one by the internal affairs team. And somehow this is where the film loses its focus perhaps it was meant to play out like a debate between why encounters happen in societies such as ours and why they shouldn’t.
But either for lack of focus or beliefs, the scriptleans in favour of encounters to ensure ‘justice’in a creaky system that is a punishment in itself. For example, there are ample references to the Delhi case culprits and that the system failed in ensuring closure. One of the Delhi rape case culprits even makes an appearance in the film; the juvenile who has now been settled elsewhere with a different identity.
In another instance, the mother of the victim, when told of the arrests, contradicts the police officer who is trying to tell her that her suffering is over; for her it is about to begin with endless trips to the courts. The police officer and she are then united in their grief it seems the grief of no quick and clear end.
But the film just doesn’t play on the grief caused by lengthy court cases. It removes nuance altogether in its portrayal of the accused. They are working-class men who guzzle whisky in their downtime and then rape and murder women.
This is their pastime and they have the routine down pat. Little effort is made to add any humanity to them even the family of the main accused is quick to argue that he could barely talk and would get the benefit of reduced mental capacity.
That a poor family is even aware of such concessions in the legal system is interesting.
In contrast, the police officers are honest, hardworking men and women who simply want to help the victim’s family bring closure and rid the world of evil. There are no corrupt police officers here who carry out encounters at the behest of the powerful and/or end up targeting innocent people, out of sheer incompetence or for money. There are no politicians in this world who might be pushing this policy on the law enforcement personnel. It’s simply the police with hearts of gold, who are playing vigilantes, the way Amitabh was an angry young man, fighting against the system.
There is little to counter all this. Just KareenaKapoor and her vague belief in following procedure and trusting the system. The morality of the matter and the havoc it can wreak is left to the audience’s imagination and understanding.
There is no mention of corruption or policemen or politicians who might turn encounters into a policy or the death of innocent people. Nor are there any rich or privileged accused who could perhaps not be disposed of this easily.
There is little debate or grey areas here, despite the film’s pretensions. And no nuance or issue to explore; something that hits home here in Pakistan with our recent debates over extrajudicial killings in Punjab and elsewhere. Or the death of Nageebullah which led to the rise of the PTM. It makes one wonder if the filmmaker, Meghna Gulzar, set out to indict the system over how it treats rapists, or the poor understanding and writing led to a less nuanced approach.
Be that as it may, there is also the larger arc of the Indian film industry where storytelling has become more cautious, especially where political commentary is concerned. Meghna Gulzar’s father, filmmaker Gulzar, lived at a time when he could make films such as Maachis, which was a beautiful and nuanced account of the insurgency in Indian Punjab. Twenty years later, it is a film that continues to haunt viewers for its depiction of those who got caught in an insurgency. And while one can debate the skills of one filmmaker compared to another, it is perhaps also about the space available in a society for difficult conversations on politics and their depiction in different forms. Conversations that lead not just to understanding but also the depiction of issues in writing and on celluloid. This is an issue that plagues the neighbours on both sides of the border we are still joined together in more ways than we realise. The writer is a joumalist.