Page 8 · National

Inquiry finds no evidence of illegal tree felling in Battagram

PESHAWAR: A fact-finding inquiry has found no evidence of unauthorised forest felling in Shamsher Valley of Allai area in Battagram district and declared that the harvesting operations were carried out under an approved working plan and sanctioned marking.

The inquiry was ordered by the chief conservator of forests (north) after a video went viral on social media alleging illegal forest felling in Compartment No 8 Gantar, Shamsher Valley, Allai, in Battagram district.

The inquiry committee consisted of Raees Khan, conservator of forests, Abbottabad, Ejazur Rehman, divisional forest officer, Torghar forest division, and Shah Fahad, divisional forest officer, Central Forest Circle, Peshawar.

Latifur Rehman, spokesperson for KP climate change, forestry, environment and wildlife department, said that contrary to claims circulating on social media through a viral video, the highlevel inquiry committee found no evidence of ‘unauthorised or illegal’ tree felling in the investigated forest compartment.

He said that the physical inspection of all 362 tree stumps, their identification marks and felling numbers, alongside a thorough examination of officialrecords, established that the trees had been felled in accordance with the duly approved marking list.

Mr Rehman also said that the committee found no substantiated evidence of collusion, complicity or deliberate negligence on the part of the forest department personnel or members of the Joint Forest Management Committee (JFMC).

He said that the investigation involved an extensive review of official documentation, physical verification of tree stumps, measurement of tree markings, geotagging, technical assessment and recording of statements from relevantstakeholders.

‘After examining the available evidence, the committee concluded that the allegations of unauthorised logging were not supported by the facts on the ground,’ he said.

The spokesperson said that according to the inquiry report, the marking of trees in Gantar Guzara Forest was carried out under the approved Revised Working Plan for Allai Valley, covering the period from 2016-17 to 2025-26.

‘On April 7, 2024, the Battagram DFO formally marked a total of 362 trees, with an estimated volume of 147,689 cubic feet. The marking had received approval from the competent departmental authorities,’ he said.

Mr Rehman said during the field inspection, the inquiry committee physically examined all 362 tree stumps and crosschecked their felling numbers, marking numbers, species, diameters and other technical particu-records, established that the trees had been felled in accordance with the duly approved marking list.

Mr Rehman also said that the committee found no substantiated evidence of collusion, complicity or deliberate negligence on the part of the forest department personnel or members of the Joint Forest Management Committee (JFMC).

He said that the investigation involved an extensive review of official documentation, physical verification of tree stumps, measurement of tree markings, geotagging, technical assessment and recording of statements from relevantstakeholders.

‘After examining the available evidence, the committee concluded that the allegations of unauthorised logging were not supported by the facts on the ground,’ he said.

The spokesperson said that according to the inquiry report, the marking of trees in Gantar Guzara Forest was carried out under the approved Revised Working Plan for Allai Valley, covering the period from 2016-17 to 2025-26.

‘On April 7, 2024, the Battagram DFO formally marked a total of 362 trees, with an estimated volume of 147,689 cubic feet. The marking had received approval from the competent departmental authorities,’ he said.

Mr Rehman said during the field inspection, the inquiry committee physically examined all 362 tree stumps and crosschecked their felling numbers, marking numbers, species, diameters and other technical particu-records, established that the trees had been felled in accordance with the duly approved marking list.

Mr Rehman also said that the committee found no substantiated evidence of collusion, complicity or deliberate negligence on the part of the forest department personnel or members of the Joint Forest Management Committee (JFMC).

He said that the investigation involved an extensive review of official documentation, physical verification of tree stumps, measurement of tree markings, geotagging, technical assessment and recording of statements from relevantstakeholders.

‘After examining the available evidence, the committee concluded that the allegations of unauthorised logging were not supported by the facts on the ground,’ he said.

The spokesperson said that according to the inquiry report, the marking of trees in Gantar Guzara Forest was carried out under the approved Revised Working Plan for Allai Valley, covering the period from 2016-17 to 2025-26.

‘On April 7, 2024, the Battagram DFO formally marked a total of 362 trees, with an estimated volume of 147,689 cubic feet. The marking had received approval from the competent departmental authorities,’ he said.

Mr Rehman said during the field inspection, the inquiry committee physically examined all 362 tree stumps and crosschecked their felling numbers, marking numbers, species, diameters and other technical particu-records, established that the trees had been felled in accordance with the duly approved marking list.

Mr Rehman also said that the committee found no substantiated evidence of collusion, complicity or deliberate negligence on the part of the forest department personnel or members of the Joint Forest Management Committee (JFMC).

He said that the investigation involved an extensive review of official documentation, physical verification of tree stumps, measurement of tree markings, geotagging, technical assessment and recording of statements from relevantstakeholders.

‘After examining the available evidence, the committee concluded that the allegations of unauthorised logging were not supported by the facts on the ground,’ he said.

The spokesperson said that according to the inquiry report, the marking of trees in Gantar Guzara Forest was carried out under the approved Revised Working Plan for Allai Valley, covering the period from 2016-17 to 2025-26.

‘On April 7, 2024, the Battagram DFO formally marked a total of 362 trees, with an estimated volume of 147,689 cubic feet. The marking had received approval from the competent departmental authorities,’ he said.

Mr Rehman said during the field inspection, the inquiry committee physically examined all 362 tree stumps and crosschecked their felling numbers, marking numbers, species, diameters and other technical particu-larsagainstthe originalapproved records.

‘The report categorically established that there was no discrepancy between the approved marking list and the trees found felled at the site,’ he said.

The spokesperson said that the committee also inspected adjoiningforest areas and surrounding compartments but found no evidence of freshly chopped unmarked stumps, unauthorised tree felling or any unreported forest damage.

He said that the viral social media video was also examined against official departmental records and the actual ground situation.

‘According to the inquiry findings, the timber shown in the video originated from trees felled under the duly approved marking process,’ he said.

Mr Rehman said the report explained that the timber had been temporarily stacked at different locations within the forest and along a traditional timber extraction route locally known as patro and that its temporary storage was necessitated by the closure of the access road that prevented its immediate transportation from the forest.

He said that departmental records indicate that approximately 70,886.24 cubic feet of timber had been extracted during the operation that commenced in November 2025.

The spokesperson said of the quantity, 20,111 cubic feet had already been transported to the designated roadside depot at Noghram Kas, while the remaining timber was awaiting transportation from the forest, patro andother temporary storage points.

‘Following the restoration of road access, the remaining timber is scheduled to be transported, in accordance with the prescribed procedures, to the Noghram Kas depot and subsequently to the central timber depot at Goharabad, Havelian, he said.

Mr Rehman said that after the requisite monitoring and measurement, the timber would be disposed of through a transparent open-auction process.

He also said that based on the available documentary and physical evidence, the committee found no substantiated grounds to establish that any departmental official or JFMC member had facilitated illegal logging, colluded in unauthorised tree felling or deliberately neglected official responsibilities.

The spokesperson said the committee also recommended that the competent authorities initiate a preliminary departmental inquiry into the conduct of two wildlife department officials, including Range Forest Officer (Wildlife) Fazal Wahab and head watcher Sartaj, to determine whether either official exceeded their lawful authority, interferedin the statutory affairs of the forest department or engaged in any other inappropriate conduct.

He said the committee emphasised that any departmental action must be based on verifiable evidence, due process and applicable legal requirements, while ensuring that the officials concerned are given a full and fair opportunity to present their defence.