Page 22 · Metro - Lahore

Abduction and torture charges Plea for direction to FIA to book cops dismissed

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has dismissed a petition seeking a direction to the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) to register a criminal case over alleged abduction and custodial torture of a man by Faisalabad police officials.

Justice Muhammad Jawad Zafar dismissed the petition filed by Nadeem Masih, who challenged an order of the additional district & sessions judge/ex-officio Justice of the Peace, Faisalabad.

That impugned order had disposed of his compliance petition after the FIA reported that an inquiry had been concluded and dropped.

The petitioner alleged that his brother, Naeem alias Noni, was abducted by the Crime Investigation Agency (CIA) police city officials, acting under its former head, Inspector Sadiq Cheema.He also alleged that his brother was illegally confined in police torture cells and badly beaten.

He said the torture of his brother was proved in a medicolegal certificate.

On his petition, Justice of the Peace had directed the FIA to conclude its inquiry within 30 days.

As the petitioner never challenged that order, Justice Zafar noted that it had attained finality.

The judge observed that when the FIA reported that the inquiry had been concluded and dropped, the order of justice of the peace stood complied with.

The judge examined the Torture and Custodial Death (Prevention and Punishment) Act, 2022, which gives the FIA exclusive jurisdiction to investigate such complaints, under the supervision of the National Commission for Human Rights.

He held the law does not impose on FIA an unconditional duty to register a case upon every complaint.

‘It requires the designated authority to evaluate the material and decide whether a case should be registered. A decision of that kind involves judgment, and it is precisely the kind of decision which mandamus cannot dictate,’ he maintained.

The judge said thepetitioner did not challenge that impugned decision in appeal and he had not shown the closure to be without jurisdiction or mala fide.

He said the medicolegal certificate may establish injuries, but it does not prove who caused them. ‘These remain disputed facts for a trial court to resolve, he declared, saying the petitioner could file a private complaint before the sessions court.