Page 2 · National

Private DNA test can’t override child’s legitimacy, rules LHC

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot displace the legal presumption that a child born during marriage is legitimate.

Justice Asad Ali Bajwa issued a ruling, upholding an enhanced maintenance award for a minor son against his father living in the United Kingdom.

The father, Osama Tahir, approached the high court against concurrent decisions of a Gujranwala family court and an additional district & sessions judge on the maintenance and dowry. Zainab Irfan and her minor son had filed a suit for maintenance, dower and dowryarticles. The couple had married on Aug 18, 2019, and two boys were born of wedlock.

The relationship ini-tially remained cordial but subsequently the husband allegedly expelled the wife from the matrimonial home along with the younger minor child whereas the older son remained in custody of his paternal grandparents.

The family court partly decreed the suit, awarding the minor child Rs10,000 a month, but on appeal the additional district & sessions judge raised the amount to Rs25,000 a month with a 10pc annual increase. It also awarded the mother Rs12,000 a month for the iddat period and dowry articles or their alternate value of Rs970,000.

The father disowned the younger boy and relied on a DNA test he had arranged at a UK laboratory, which reported ‘paternity excluded’.

Justice Bajwa noted that the family court had rejected the paternity plea ofthefather.

The judge held that under Article 128 of the Qanun-iShahadat Order, 1984, birth during a valid marriage is conclusive proof of legitimacy unless the husband refuses to own the child.

He noted that the petitioner’s own witnesses admitted that the marriage was intact at the birth and that he and his mother accompanied the wife to the hospital.

‘A unilateral DNA test report cannot by itself displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy pro-vided under Article 128 of the Q anun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984,’ the judge added.

He said such tests were a serious judicial act that must be approached with caution, and that the child’s welfare came first.

The wife claimed the father earned Rs1.2 million a month in the UK.

Justice Bajwa observed that the respondent (wife) gave no documentary proof, but the petitioner’s own witnesses admitted he lived in the UK and sent money into a family bank account.

The judge held that this supported the wife’s claim that the husband was earning abroad and that he failed to show the enhanced amount was excessive. He said maintenance depended on the child’s reasonable needs, including food, clothing, lodging, education and healthcare, and the father’s means. The duty arises whenever he has capacity to earn, the judge observed, and may pass to the paternal grandfather only if the father lacks the means and cannot earn.

On dowry, the judge found the partial decree showed the claim had been tested against the evidence available on record and that the petitioner failed to point out any misreading or non-reading of evidence warranting any interference in the findings of the courts below.vided under Article 128 of the Q anun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984,’ the judge added.

He said such tests were a serious judicial act that must be approached with caution, and that the child’s welfare came first.

The wife claimed the father earned Rs1.2 million a month in the UK.

Justice Bajwa observed that the respondent (wife) gave no documentary proof, but the petitioner’s own witnesses admitted he lived in the UK and sent money into a family bank account.

The judge held that this supported the wife’s claim that the husband was earning abroad and that he failed to show the enhanced amount was excessive. He said maintenance depended on the child’s reasonable needs, including food, clothing, lodging, education and healthcare, and the father’s means. The duty arises whenever he has capacity to earn, the judge observed, and may pass to the paternal grandfather only if the father lacks the means and cannot earn.

On dowry, the judge found the partial decree showed the claim had been tested against the evidence available on record and that the petitioner failed to point out any misreading or non-reading of evidence warranting any interference in the findings of the courts below.