Page 6 · Editorial

Predatory medicine

‘Medicine carries a morality that is destroyed when the emphasis is placed on the bottom line. Unless humanism and professionalism remain, medicine will become just another commodity in life’s marketplace.’Dr William W. Parmley MEDICINE has traditionally been regarded as a profession founded on trust, compassion and an ethical commitment to heal. Patients entrust doctors with their bodies, their fears and, often, their lives. This relationship rests on an implicit promise: that medical decisions will be guided by the patient’s best interests. But what happens when the business of medicine begins to take precedence over the practice of medicine? In his book Predatory Medicine, US cardiologist Jack vangrow draws attention to an uncomfortable reality: healthcare can become an extractive enterprise in which patients are exploited. He describes how both practitioners and institutions who should be protecting patients, instead exploit patients’ limited medical knowledge and trust.

The commercialisation of medicine may not be inherently unethical. Private hospitals, clinics, labs and pharmaceutical firms have an important role in healthcare delivery. Medical innovation and research require investment, and healthcare professionals deserve fair remuneration. The problem arises when profit becomes the dominant consideration and the patient’s wellbeing becomes secondary.

Predatory medicine describes many practices that lead to profit-making: unnecessary investigations, excessive prescriptions, avoidable surgical procedures, inappropriate hospital admissions, inflated bills and the promotion of expensive treatments when cheaper, equally effective alternatives exist.

The fundamental problem is the profound imbalance of knowledge and power between doctors and patients. Most patients cannot independently assess whether an investigation is necessary, whether a diagnosis is accurate or whether a proposed intervention offers meaningful benefit.

They depend on their physician’s integrity and competence. When that trust is exploited, the consequences can be both financial and physical.

Vangrow highlights the culture of professional complicity: doctors who recognise questionable practices but remain silent to protect their careers, professional relationships or financial interests. Predatory medicine, therefore, is not simply about a few unethical practitioners; it becomes embedded in the institutional culture.Vangrow’s observations are highly relevant for Pakistan, where private healthcare has become a hugely lucrative business, while a chronically underfunded public health system struggles to provide even basic services. The private medical sector continues to grow exponentially, with private hospitals, specialist clinics, diagnostic labs and pharmaceutical firms dominating healthcare delivery.

According to Pakistan’s National Health Accounts 2021-22, total health expenditure stood at approximately Rs1.96 trillion, with the private sector accounting for 52.6 per cent. Much of this expenditure comes directly from household pockets. The World Bank’s latest available data show that out-of-pocket payments accounted for approximately 53pc of Pakistan’s current health expenditure in 2023. These figures illustrate the extent to which healthcare costs are transferred from the state to individual households. They also reveal a stark contradiction: healthcare is a rap-idly expanding commercial market in a country where millions cannot afford basic treatment.

Public health expenditure remains around one per cent of GDP, leaving government hospitals chronically under-resourced, overcrowded and struggling with shortages of medicines, equipment and personnel. While wealthier Pakistanis can access private healthcare, the poor have to suffer the indignity of treatment at government facilities, underscoring a deeply unequal healthcare system.

A particular aspect of predatory medicine is to medicalise ordinary social problems, resulting in unnecessary lab tests, polypharmacy and doctor shopping. This is compounded by potential conflicts of interest involving pharmaceutical firms, labs, medical equipment suppliers and healthcare providers.

Pakistan’s regulatory institutions Provincial Healthcare Commissions (PHCs), PMDC andDRAP have important responsibilities of licensing, quality assurance, professional conduct and patient safety. However, enforcement remains poor. Regulation must be more effective and independent. PHCs need resources and authority to monitor private hospitals and diagnostic facilities. Transparent disclosure of treatment costs, standardised billing, independent clinical audits and accessible patient complaint mechanisms are required.

Addressing predatory medicine requires more than asking individual doctors to behave ethically. It requires changing the structures and incentives within which healthcare is practised.

A functioning, adequately funded public health system is essential not only for providing services to those who cannot afford private treatment but also for preventing the private sector from becoming the only realistic option for millions.

Financial relationships between doctors, pharmaceutical firms, labs and hospitals should be disclosed and appropriately regulated. Clinical decisions must be based on evidence and patient need, not commercial incentives. Medical education must place greater emphasis on professional ethics, the social responsibilities of medicine and the doctor-patient relationship. Being a good doctor is not simply about diagnostic accuracy or technical competence; it is also about recognising vulnerability, avoiding unnecessary interventions and respecting patients’ autonomy.

Healthcare is not like any other commodity and a patient seeking treatment is not an ordinary consumer making a purchase in a competitive marketplace. Illness creates vulnerability, distress, dependence and desperation. The relationship between a doctor and patient cannot be driven by market principles. In Pakistan, the ethical foundations of medical practice receive insufficient attention. We may have internationally accredited hospitals and specialists, yet still fail in our obligation to provide equitable and compassionate care.

The purpose of medicine is to heal, relieve suffering and protect human dignity. When profit displaces these obligations, medicine becomes predatory. We not only need more hospitals and better technology, but also a commitment to the ethics and social responsibility that should define the medical profession. • The wnter is professor ementus of psychiatry, Aga Khan University.

mmkarticle@gmail.com