KARACHI: The federal government on Tuesday reminded PPP Chairman Bilawal BhuttoZardari that they were ‘part of the same government’, after the latter launched into a hardhitting diatribe over the question of new provinces, expressing support for several opposition demands and questioning past decisions and actions taken by the ruling coalition.In one of his starkest warnings yet amid the ongoing debate over the creation of new administrative units, Mr Bhutto-Zardari expressed the fear that any ‘forced’ attempt to carve up Sindh into new provinces would lead to bloodshed, and insisted on a ‘political and democratic reset’ to meet the growing challenges of governance, economy and poverty.’We do not want to see any division imposed through force.
If Sindh is divided forcibly, questions will be asked about the blood that will be spilled on the streets of Karachi,’ he said.
The warning came during the PPP chief’s remarks at the Karachi Press Club, where he was responding to questions after addressing a ‘Meet the Press’ programme, and sought to clarify the party’s position and reservations over the ongoing debate, and a host of other issues.
Opposition to referendum During his press talk, Mr Bhutto-Zardari admitted that he did not know what the federal government was thinking’We do not want to see any division imposed through force.
If Sindh is divided forcibly, questions will be asked about the blood that will be spilled on the streets of Karachi,’ he said.
The warning came during the PPP chief’s remarks at the Karachi Press Club, where he was responding to questions after addressing a ‘Meet the Press’ programme, and sought to clarify the party’s position and reservations over the ongoing debate, and a host of other issues.
Opposition to referendum During his press talk, Mr Bhutto-Zardari admitted that he did not know what the federal government was thinkingon the issue of a ‘governance reset’.
On Interior Minister Mohsin Nagvi’s recommendation of holding a referendum to decide on the creation of administrative units, the PPP chairman pointed to the ‘intention’ behind the proposed action.
‘I do not understand what Mohsin Bhai is trying to do,’ he said, adding: ‘In our history, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one.
Talking about his proposal for a ‘political reset’, he said: ‘I will try to develop that consensus, and I would like to create a consensus for it in my own party so that we can engage other political parties.
On the issue of new administrative units, he said, ‘Up until today, neither the prime minister nor a single member of the provinces has brought up the issue with the president of Pakistan or me’.
‘Even the cabinet has not discussed the matter, let alone the parliament [..] So, how could it be that federal ministers are talking about it of their own accord,’ he asked.
The PPP chairman said he would like to believe that Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has ‘enough authority over his own ministers’, adding that he had invited the premier to hold talks with the Sindh government on public issues, and also suggested that the premier hold cabinet meetings in each province.
Acknowledging mistakes ‘I believe the system has not collapsed, but it has been made to collapse,’ Mr BhuttoZardari said, while acknowledging his own role in the matter.
‘Everyone makes mistakes, but there comes a time when you must fix those mistakes. How do we fix that?’ he asked, rhetorically.
He also voiced his strong opposition to the proposal to hold a referendum on creating new provinces, questioning the intent behind it, saying that while his party lawmakers were under pressure on the issue, they would not succumb to it.
ThePPPleaderalsoquestionedthe current status of the judiciary, particularly in the wake of the 27th Amendment, which he had strongly advocated for at the time of its passagejustayearago.
He questioned whether the constitutional court that had been formed had the public’s confidence. ‘If the lawyers and judges themselves do not have confidence in the courts, then the system did not collapse, but was made to collapse.
While clarifying that he was not advocating a rollback, Mr Bhutto-Zardari asserted that the 26th Amendment was passed with’bilateral agreement, if not complete consensus’, but the 27th Amendment was ‘passed neither through political consensus nor bilateral agreement; it was passed with brute majority’.
He called for engaging with the opposition on judicial reforms and termed it a requirement for the ‘political, public and democratic reset’, adding that without such a reset, the public’s key issues of inflation and unemployment cannot be addressed.
Soft corner for opposition He also openly expressed support for the release of former prime minister and PTI founder Imran Khan,and all other political prisoners.
‘If we want the system to be reset and the parliament to start functioning, vengeful actions will need to be stopped. How much revenge will you take after all?’ he said.
The PPP chairman said not only should vengeful actions be halted but the ‘tradition of revenge inserted in Pakistan’s politics’ should be ended forever. He also called for efforts to ensure that there is no political prisoner in Pakistan, terming it necessary for the ‘system to function.
‘What a weird country this is; since 1947, whoever becomes the prime minister goes to jail, whoever gets out of jail goes to sit in PM House,’ he remarked.
When asked whether he considered Mr Khan a political prisoner, Mr Bhutto-Zardari responded in the affirmative.
Noting that the PTI had made mistakes as well, the PPP chief said, ‘One day, I hope no prime minister should have to go to jail, and for that, we need to develop consensus.
Reiterating his call for electoral reforms, Mr. Bhutto-Zardari also stressed the need to restore the PTI and wider opposition’s trust in parliament. He referred to the revocation of PTI’s election symbol ahead of the 2024 general elections as an ‘injustice’, and called for restoring the reserved seats to the party that had won them.’What happened with the reserved seats was a joke,’ he said, adding that the opposition was notonly deprived of the reserved seats, they were also’pocketed’bythe treasurybenches.
‘It is a confidence-building measure that we, without any preconditions, return the reserved seats to the opposition, which is their right,’ said the PPP chief, whose party was also among the beneficiaries of the reserved seatscase.
Tarar’s response The aggressive stance adopted by the PPP chairman appeared to be a continuation of his recent change in tone towards the government, mainly following the growing debate over the creation of new provinces and administrative units.
Perhaps this was why Federal Information Minister Attaullah Tarar responded directly to the PPP chairman’s latest remarks, suggesting that his criticism was largely a reaction to the ongoing public debate over the creation of new provinces.
‘Look, we are part of the same government.
Come and sit down [with us] so we can make decision for the betterment of the people and the country,’ he told Mr Bhutto-Zardari.
‘The public wants a good government that is accountable ... You and all of us have been part of this system for decades. Today, we cannot separate ourselves from the weaknesses of the system,’ he said.
The minister said the issue should be considered constructively, rather than being turned into a political controversy, maintaining that past misuse of referendums could not justify depriving citizens of their constitutional right.
He reminded the PPP chief that this debate was raging among the masses. ‘Will you silence the people? Will you stop them from talking about improving governance? This debate will happen in parliament and outside it,’ Mr Tarar said.
‘The people are the ultimate decision-makers. If the people of Pakistan and Sindh want more provinces, then make them; otherwise, don’t,’ he added.