Page 11 · International

Inside Deutsche Bank: the scandals of a banking giant

A NEW investigation into the internal workings of one of the world’s largest banks reveals that it repeatedly missed warning signs of possible money laundering and sanctions violations, bent its own rules for powerful clients and allowed business considerations to override its own compliance regime.The files also expose the intimate financial information of extremely powerful people.

Inside Deutsche Bank is the outcome of a months-long investigation into around 15 million internal files, emails from senior executives, secret risk assessments, suspicious transaction reports, private information about billionaires, oligarchs, politicians and royalty.

All of this adds up to the largest cache of internal documents ever leaked to journalists from within a bank.

The leak, provided via two whistleblowers, was shared with Indian journalist Josy Joseph and South African journalist Khadija Sharife.

Barracuda Media, a non-profit vehicle, was established to analyse the data and share it with reporters from more than 50 global media outlets spanning over50 countries.

Besides Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein, who both famously used Deutsche Bank after other institutions shied away, the leak holds extensive details on Vladimir Putin-allied oligarchs like Oleg Deripaska and Roman Abramovich.

Their clients include a company whose ultimate beneficial owner was a Saudi businessman named on the famous ‘Golden Chain’list of purported Al Qaeda sponsors. Deutsche Bank also helped process payments linked to Rifaat al-Assad, Syria’s former vice-president known as the ‘Butcher of Hama’ for his role in a bloody 1982 crackdown.

In a response to the wide range of topics raised in the leak, Deutsche Bank said matters raised by reporters ‘date back many years, in some cases decades’. Where relevant, the bank said, these matters were reviewed at the time and were discussed with regulators and competent authorities as necessary.

Over the coming weeks, Inside Deutsche Bank media partners will publish many more stories drawn from the files.

Epstein and Trump connections Deutsche Bank accepted Epstein as a client in 2013, years after his conviction for soliciting prostitution from a minor. The leak shows the bank later identified nearly $600 million in suspicious transactions involving him and his network more than twice the amount previously publicly known.

In a statement, the bank said it ‘acknowledges its error of onboarding Epstein in 2013 and regrets our historical connection with him. We have cooperated withregulatory and law enforcement agencies and the US Congress regarding their investigations and have been transparent in addressing these matters in parallel.

When Trump won his first presidential term on Nov 8, 2016, Deutsche Bank faced an almost unprecedented situation: the president-elect was also one of its most controversial borrowers. The bank created a special project around him, codenamed ‘Novus Ordo’ (New Order).

Trump-related documents were secured. Access was restricted. Communications were encrypted. Personal contacts minimised. But there was a larger problem: Trump and his businesses still wanted things from Deutsche Bank, like changes to existing loans.

The relationship had already gone spectacularly wrong once. After Trump failed to repay a loan for his Chicago tower during the financial crisis, he sued Deutsche Bank for $3 billion, essentially blaming it for a crisis that had damaged his business (the case was settled before trial). Deutsche Bank continued doing business with him. Then came Russia.

As American prosecutors examined alleged Russian interference in the 2016 election, leading Democrats in the US Congress wanted to know whether Russians had guaranteed Trump’s Deutsche Bank loans, and whether Trump-related entities had ever raised wider moneylaunderingconcerns.

The bank conducted an extensive internal review. It was not aware, according to an internal email prepared by its New York branch in 2019, ‘of any Bank-related links between President Trump and Russia related to Mr. Trump’s business with Deutsche Bank.But a 2020 memo from Brian Hagerty, then the bank’s director of its US financial crimes intelligence unit, references transactions connected to two Trump companies named DT Marks Baku LLC and THC Baku Services LLC. Both companies are listed as owned by Trump in his 2015 financial disclosure report filed with the US Office of Government Ethics.

The memo stated that neither company were Deutsche Bank customers. But transactions involving the companies had raised internal concerns over potential links to the Azerbaijani and Russian laundromats, two notorious money laundering schemes.

The Hagerty memo notes that in 2018, a transaction between THC Baku Services LLC and ‘an entity reportedly associated to the Russian Laundromat scheme’ was ‘included in a SAR.

Deutsche Bank would not comment on Trump. It said in general terms, ‘banks are legally prohibited from commenting on their discussions with supervisory authorities in the US and on Suspicious Activity Reports, including their existence or non-existence.

Reporters also found that by 2017, with Trump well into his first term, a Deutsche Bank employee accidentally sent an outside party a link containing financial information for 1,586 customers. Three accounts allegedly belonged to the newly-inaugurated president; these were called ‘DT’ and ‘DJT’ internally.

Managers debated whether Trump had to be informed of the leak, but concluded he did not. One manager called it a ‘brilliant outcome.

‘Good and bad oligarchs’ Russia, and the bank’s dealings with it, were among the whistleblowers’ primary concerns when contacting reporters with their information.

After Putin annexed Crimea in 2014, Western sanctions forced banks to decide which Russian clients were still palatable. ‘We started making lists,’ a former Deutsche Bank insider told reporters. ‘Good and bad oligarchs.

The leaked documents show the bank repeatedly facilitating sanctioned or politically exposed Russians, and remaining reluctant to fully abandon its long Russian entanglement.

Documents show that by May 2020, with expansion of certain Russian business being planned by bank leaders, the move was described by one anti-financial-crime specialist as akin to throwing her team in front of a train.

Russia has continued to haunt the bank; early this year, German investigators searched Deutsche Bank’s Frankfurt headquarters in an investigation involving transactions reportedly associated with the oligarch Abramovich.

Through correspondent banking, the invisible plumbing of global finance, Deutsche Bank moves money for other banks, giving them access to euros, dollars and international markets. It is lucrative and exceptionally difficult to police, and the underlying customers may be several steps removed from Deutsche Bank itself. Criminals, sanctioned entities and shell companies can disappear inside millions of ostensibly legitimate transactions.

Can a bank reliably identify money laundering, drug trafficking and human smuggling within such a system? ‘No,’ said Ulrich Göres, former head of Deutsche Bank’s anti-financial crime department. Why do banks do it? ‘For banking for high risk countries, and for high risk industries generally, higher fees can be charged.

In one of its biggest scandals to date, Deutsche Bank was a major correspondent bank for Danske Bank’s Estonian branch.

Roughly 200 billion euros flowed through Danske Bank’s Estonian branch between 2007 and 2015, much of it involving customers from Russia and other former Soviet states. Deutsche Bank helped process international payments for the branch as a correspondent bank.

In 2020, German authorities fined the bank 13.5 million euros for failing to promptly report ‘suspicious transactions’. Such penalties are a weak deterrent, Göres said, unless the penalty payments exceed the income generated previously.

On correspondent banking, Deutsche Bank said: ‘Over the past decade, Deutsche Bank has substantially reduced its risk profile in this business, including exiting high-risk clients and countries. At the same time the bank has materially strengthened its financial crime controls and expertise ... to manage the inherently elevated financial-crime risk in correspondent banking through significant investments.

A detailed version of this article can be accessed on D awn.com