Page 27 · Metro - Peshawar

Study cautions against ‘plans to split country into multiple regions’

PESHAWAR: A study regarding the creation of new provinces has warned that ‘plans to split the country into multiple regions’ rely on flawed financial savings estimates and misdiagnose institutional decay, so redrawing maps will not fix poor governance unlesslocalgovernments and underlying systems are reformed.

The report, titled Governance Failure in Pakistan What New Provinces Would & Would Not Fix, has been prepared by the Advocacy for Sustainable Policy and Implementation Reforms(Aspire-KP), a think tank, advocating for reforms in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

The 139-page report, authored by former civil servant Sahibzada Saeed Ahmad, was unveiled at a seminar organised by the Aspire-KP in collaboration with the Department of Political Science, University of Peshawar, here on Tuesday.

It analysed the two claims, including that the creation of new provinces will address governance failures and that converting the country’s existing 32 administrative divisions into provinces, alongside Islamabad, will generate savings of Rs317.87 billion annually.

However, the study distinguished between failure of the constitutional system and failure of institutions operating within it and located the difficultyinthe second.

‘If the design is broadly sound but institutions do not operate within it, territorial change would not by itselfaddress the underlying failure, it said.

The study pointed out that the case for large-scale territorial restructuring has not yet been established on governance or fiscal grounds.

‘The quantified saving requires substantial correction, while the governance failures examined in this paper appear to arise predominantly from institutional conditions that do not disappear when a provincial boundary is redrawn. A future case for restructuring would therefore require clearer criteria, unit-by-unit fiscal viability, a worked transition and apportionment framework, constitutional legitimacy, institutional redesign and evidence that the problems attributed to territorial scale cannot be addressed more effectively through deeper devolution,’ it said.

The reportalsosaid thateven after new provinces were formed, two assets did not divide at all.’A new province would come into existence with no allocation of water: the Accord of 1991 is a compact among exactly four provinces and contains no formula for admitting a new claimant. And dividing a coastal province leaves one successor holding the port and another without the revenue base that sustains it,’ it said.

The report said that the costing in circulation does not support the saving it claims. ‘Its totals reconcile, but the existing-cost column is substantially drawn at whole-function level while the proposed-cost column is drawn at secretariat-establishment level. The difference between cost bases cannot reliably be reported as a saving,’ it said.

It also said that the allowance multiplier applied to proposed employee costs appears higher than the ratio reflected in the budget data, while the wider concern about growth in provincial administrative expenditureis supported by the fiscal record.

The report said that neither resolves the underlying comparability problem. The exercise also leaves major items outside the calculation, including capital establishment, transition and apportionment.

The report said that available evidence does not establish that governance outcomes improve simply because federating units become smaller. Much of the observed variation occurs below the provincial level and is associated with institutional and local conditions, according to it.

The report said that fiscal viability must be tested unit by unit.

‘Some of the smallest proposed units would carry a high fixed constitutional and administrative cost relative to their indicative fiscal capacity,’ it said.

The study noted that capital and transition costs were not adequately incorporated.

‘New provinces would require constitutional offices, assemblies, courts, secretariats and associated infrastructure. Pensions, liabilities, assets and employee apportionment would also require settlement, and comparative experience shows that such issues can persist for many years,’ it said.

The report said that while Article 239(4) of the Constitution remained in force, alteration of provincial limits required the prescribed two-thirds approval of the affected provincial assembly in addition to parliamentary supermajorities.

It added that Pakistan had no completed precedent under the Constitution for dividing an existing province into successorprovinces.

‘Any attempt first to remove the provincial-consent safeguard would raise a separate constitutional and federal question,’ it said. The report also said that new executives, legislatures, courts and bureaucracies would create political and administrative constituencies of their own.

It said that the political-economy effect should be treated as part of the restructuring decision even where it cannot be reduced to a precise fiscal figure.

According to it, Article 140-A already provided a constitutional basis for bringing government closer to citizens, but meaningful local devolution has remained intermittent, uneven and vulnerable to reversal.

The report said that the institutional conditions required for successful territorial restructuring substantially overlap with those required for meaningful devolution within the present structure: predictable fiscal rules, functioning local government, controlled administrative expenditure and effective public institutions.

It, however, said that territorial restructuring could still constitute a fundamental reform if undertaken by a genuinely representative government after open public debate and with meaningful consent.

Earlier, former chief secretary and Aspire-KP chairman Mohammad Shehzad Arbab, in his opening remarks, said that the proposal to create new provinces or administrative units needed to be debated and analysed and see which governance model was better to replace the existing system.

Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency president Ahmad Bilal Mehboob commended Sahibzada Saeed and Aspire-KP for the research work and holding public debate on the important issue.