Page 5 · National

Bilawal’s ‘bloodshed’ warning sparks political backlash

ISLAMABAD: Senior leaders of the ruling PML-N and Jamaat-i-Islami (JI) and MQM-Pakistan on Wednesday accused PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari of ‘political hypocrisy’ after he warned of bloodshed in Sindh over the creation of new provinces and called for a ‘political reset’.

Federal ministers pointed to the PPP’s role in passing recent constitutional amendments and sharing power in Islamabad, while Mr Bhutto-Zardari urged his allies to have the ‘courage to listen to the truth’ in a TV interview.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif led the PML-N’s counteroffensive, questioning Mr Bhutto-Zardari’s moral authority to lecture his allies after 18 years of PPP governance in Sindh and a coalition partnership with the PML-N in the federal government since 2022.

‘He who claims equity must come with clean hands,’ Mr Asif wrote on X, quoting a legal maxim. ‘Are your own hands clean? Do you have the right to lecture others or issue threats?’

The defence minister also defended Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s proposal to hold a referendum on creating new administrative units — a suggestion Mr Bhutto-Zardari dismissed on Tuesday as ‘historically undemocratic’.

Mr Asif argued that while parliament would debate any ‘system reset’, the public could not be deprived of its fundamental right to weigh in.

‘The pinnacle of legitimacy would be reached if the public opinion is also taken into account along with that of parliament,’ he said, adding that no politician was exempt from accountability, a veiled reference to calls for the release of jailed ex-premier Imran Khan.

No system could reset without public support, he said, adding that if the PPP leader was talking about a system collapse, everyone connected to the system had to take stock of their responsibilities as well.

Taking a jab at the PPP’s governance record, Mr Asif remarked sarcastically that ‘Sindh has turned into paradise’ and accused the PPP of reaping the benefits of the coalition while the PML-N and the country bore the losses.

Minister of State for Interior Tallal Chaudhry echoed these views, describing Mr Bhutto-Zardari as a ‘champion’ of the Constitution in theory, whose practical performance was ‘zero’.

Mr Chaudhry said the PPP held power in three provinces and Gilgit-Baltistan, as well as the offices of the president and Senate chairman, yet acted like an opposition party.

He accused Mr Bhutto-Zardari of hypocrisy for opposing new administrative units in Sindh while supporting the creation of a south Punjab province, and for distancing himself from the 27th Constitutional Amendment after previously praising the establishment of a constitutional court. ‘Sins are not washed away in this manner,’ he said.

Referring to the PPP chief’s warning of ‘bloodshed’ if Sindh was forcibly divided, the interior minister said, ‘The question is: Does casting a vote cause blood to flow, or does it stop bloodshed? You always say the decision should come through the ballot, not the bullet. So when did you start fearing the vote?’

Minister for National Health Services Mustafa Kamal, whose party is part of the ruling coalition, also condemned the bloodshed remarks as ‘regrettable and painful’, characterising it as an attempt to intimidate the Urdu-speaking communities in urban areas of Sindh.

He added the PPP would be responsible if ‘even a single drop of blood is shed,’ noting that the party has been at the helm in Sindh for nearly two decades.

Accusing the PPP of centralising power, siphoning off Rs22tr received under the NFC Award over 17 years and neglecting Karachi development, the minister claimed his party had tried to empower local governments through the 26th and 27th Amendments, ‘but the PPP crushed’ the move. He argued that the Constitution could be amended further to remove procedural hurdles to creating smaller administrative units.

‘Have courage to listen’

In an interview on Hum News, the PPP chief pushed back against the barrage of criticism, arguing that his status as a ‘major stakeholder’ in the ruling coalition was precisely why his allies needed to heed his warnings.

‘You may disagree with my suggestions, but at least listen,’ Mr Bhutto-Zardari said. ‘You should have the courage to listen to the truth. Because I am a stakeholder, I am saying: Come to your senses’.

Taking a swipe at Mr Naqvi, who also serves as Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) chairman, Mr Bhutto-Zardari quipped whether only the PCB chairman had the right to tell how and why the system has collapsed. ‘If a reset has to happen, then has the PCB been given the responsibility that you have all powers to decide how the system will be reset, whether provinces should be divided? ... Should I go home quietly? This is not possible,’ he said.

Responding to criticism over his warning about possible bloodshed in Sindh, he said it was neither a threat nor a call for street protests, rather he was simply conveying people’s perspective in light of Sindh’s turbulent history since the 1980s. He cautioned that while he did not want unrest, the law and order situation could deteriorate so badly that it would be difficult to put out the ‘fire’.

Amid regional tensions with India and Afghanistan, the former foreign minister warned, ‘Elites do not have the idea of what kind of difficulties Pakistanis are facing’ in the context of economic impact of ongoing conflicts in the region.

Terming the government’s reaction to Maulana Fazlur Rehman’s criticism ‘completely frivolous, irresponsible conduct’, the PPP chairman cautioned the PML-N government against opening multiple political fronts against the JUI-F, PTI and then PPP.

‘I suggested to everyone that a political reset is needed, a democratic reset is needed, so that instead of politicians grabbing each other’s collars, fighting each other, we all join hands to pull the public out of this hardship,’ he said.

Zardari’s resignation

Jamaat-i-Islami Emir Hafiz Naeemur Rehman also joined the chorus of criticism, asking Mr Bhutto-Zardari to review his party’s history, specifically the ethnic riots triggered by the 1972 language bill in Sindh, before warning others.

At a news conference in Islamabad, the JI emir said his party supported new administrative units, but through constitutional means.

Noting that President Asif Ali Zardari was elected with PML-N-led coalition’s support and had signed the order imposing governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, he said, ‘If the government lacked legitimacy, [President] Zardari should resign.’

ECP officials parry criticism

When asked about the PPP chairman’s remarks regarding the return of reserved seats to the opposition, Election Commission of Pakistan officials said Mr Bhutto-Zardari had ignored legal facts, as the PTI had failed to meet the constitutional requirement for reserved seats.

Mr Bhutto-Zardari, however, explained in a TV interview on Wednesday evening that he had talked about such an arrangement only if a ‘political reset’ was needed.

Speaking to Geo News, he said his party respected the people’s mandate, and for that he was even open to fresh elections within six months, instead of the so-called referendum, betting that the PPP would emerge victorious once again.