Page 7 · Opinion

Federal footprint

THE recent remarks by some ministers about Pakistan’s governance system having collapsed have reignited calls for creating new provinces in the country. However, resistance in Sindh as well as concerns about the potentially high cost of any such project show that redrawing boundaries risks political and administrative polarisation.

Global experience offers a clear lesson. Expanding states — as in Nigeria’s 36-state model — multiplies administrative overhead and financial dependence without empowering citizens. Conversely, China’s growth proves that true economic dynamism stems from fiscally autonomous city governments. Rather than carving out new provinces, Pakistan must bring into play all the provisions in its Constitution related to the devolution of administrative, policing and revenue-retention powers directly to elected mayors in major urban hubs, alongside strict, performance-based accountability for due public service delivery.

Simultaneously, the state does need to curb unsustainable expenditure at the Centre to rescue the stagnant economy from its chronic reliance on foreign loans and remittances. Trimming Islamabad’s footprint requires abolishing overlapping ministries in devolved sectors, privatising loss-making state-owned enterprises, and halting parliamentarians’ discretionary development funds.

Pakistan’s crisis does not owe its origin to a deficit of provincial maps, but to a lack of local empowerment and fiscal discipline. Empowering cities while right-sizing the Centre appears to be the only available and practical path towards self-reliance.

Arshad Kamal Karachi