ISLAMABAD: A study of tobacco growers in three districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa has revealed major gaps in compliance with Pakistan Tobacco Board (PTB) regulations, raising concerns over unregulated purchasing practices and the possible diversion of tobacco into illicit supply chains.
The study, titled ‘Assessment of Tobacco-Leaf Production, Marketing and Purchasing Practices’, was conducted by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR) and its findings were presented at a gathering on tobacco.
The survey covered 1,200 tobacco farmers in Swabi, Mardan and Charsadda, examining purchasing arrangements, pricing, payments and regulatory compliance.
Conducted between September and October, the survey interviewed 660 growers in Swabi, 360 in Mardan and 180 in Charsadda to identify problems faced by farmers and companies during the tobacco purchasing season and possible measures to address them.
An official described Swabi as the ‘House of Tobacco’ because of its quality production and the large proportion of its population involved in tobacco cultivation. Under the existing PTB regulatory framework, tobacco purchases are subject to government-notified weighted average prices intended to protect farmers. Companies and dealers are also required to fulfil their announced purchasing quotas, including any additional surplus quantities assigned by the board.
However, the study identified considerable gaps between these requirements and prevailing market practices.
It found that 45 per cent of farmers had no written purchasing agreement before planting, while 52pc reported selling tobacco to buyers with whom they had no direct written agreement.
Significant price differences were also recorded. Farmers selling to multinational tobacco companies received an average of Rs720 per kilogram compared to Rs559 from other companies and Rs471 from dealers.
Among farmers who faced difficulties selling tobacco outside formal agreements, 85pc reported being offered prices below the official PTB rate.
The survey also highlighted concerns over payment practices. Among farmers selling through non-contracted arrangements, 52pc reported receiving payments in cash, while 36pc received payment on the spot. The study raised concerns that tobacco purchased outside formal agreements, including through transactions that bypass buying depots, could weaken transparency and traceability, creating opportunities for produce to enter undocumented supply chains.
It warned that such gaps at the beginning of the tobacco supply chain could undermine government efforts to curb illicit trade.
Commenting on the findings, IPOR Executive Director Tariq Junaid said: ‘The issue is the gaps in compliance with the regulatory framework governing tobacco purchasing. When tobacco is traded outside formal agreements through third-party buyers, farmers face greater uncertainty and the risk of receiving prices below those prescribed by the Pakistan Tobacco Board.’
‘Stronger enforcement of existing regulations is essential to address these gaps,’ he added.
The study also found that 62pc of farmers identified increased purchasing agreements or higher procurement quotas from multinational companies as the most important improvement needed in the existing system, indicating a preference for structured purchasing arrangements.