ISLAMABAD: A report released by the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) on Wednesday said Pakistan’s 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments had led to ‘systemic judicial capture’.
Passed in October 2024, the 26th Amendment created constitutional benches in the Supreme Court, with judges selected by a reconstituted Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), in which judges no longer held a majority.
Barely a year later, the 27th Amendment replaced these benches with the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), overhauled the judicial system and granted immunity to government officials.
Titled Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, the report said the country’s higher courts no longer had the institutional safeguards needed to ensure judicial independence under international law.
It noted that these two amendments represented a decisive break from the independent judicial model established after the 2009 restoration of the judiciary. It also observed that this erosion of judicial independence was achieved through formal constitutional amendments rather than the overt removal of judges.
The report said that although the government justified the 26th and 27th Amendments as measures to curb judicial overreach, clear case backlogs, depoliticise the SC’s jurisdiction, and give parliament a standard role in appointing judges, these arguments did not warrant altering the judicial structure in violation of Pakistan’s obligations under international law.
While acknowledging that the SC had previously encroached on the roles of other institutions, the report noted that parliament failed to address these flaws in a manner that preserved judicial independence.
The report called on the government to conduct a comprehensive and transparent review of the amendments and their implementation, with broad public consultation, to ensure compliance with international law.
It also urged the government to seek technical assistance from the UN special rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers and invite the expert to visit Pakistan.
The report recommended that the JCP introduce a transparent process for selecting judges and publish reasons for every appointment. It also called on the commission to stop transferring high court judges without their consent.
It further advised the Supreme Judicial Council to define ‘inefficiency’ in line with international standards, limiting its use to cases of serious incompetence that made a judge unfit to perform their duties.— Dawn Report