HYDERABAD: The Sindh High Court on Wednesday expressed annoyance at provincial authorities over non-compliance with its earlier order regarding submission of a comprehensive plan to curb pollution of the Indus River and directed the court’s additional registrar to conduct a comprehensive site inspection and submit a report within one week.
A division bench comprising Justice Adnanul Karim Memon and Justice Mohammad Jaffer Raza also bound authorities not to allow pollution of the river around Kotri Barrage at any cost.
It ordered the authorities to ensure their personal participation in the exercise and provide all relevant records and technical assistance to the court official for the inspection.
The bench adjourned the hearing till Nov 25.
The court said that the additional registrar would conduct inspection along with photograph/video of the entire site.
He would be accompanied by Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa) head, head of Hyderabad Water & Sewerage Corporation (HWSC), representatives of Public Health Engineering (PHE) Hyderabad, Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (HMC) and other heads concerned, who shall extend full cooperation.
The court also expressed strong displeasure over the comments filed by respondents, and the lethargic, casual and indifferent attitude demonstrated by authorities concerned.
It referred to its Nov 3 order, directing Sepa, PHE, local government departments and authorities to submit a comprehensive fact-finding report supported by scientific water testing, identification of pollution sources, joint site inspection, assessment of existing wastewater treatment facilities, enforcement measures and a practical time-bound action plan.
The bench noted that respondents failed to furnish the requisite factual and scientific report, reflecting a disturbing lack of seriousness towards an issue directly affecting public health, environmental protection and fundamental rights of citizens.
‘Such nonchalant conduct particularly in a matter involving pollution of Indus river is wholly unacceptable,’ said the court.
The bench passed the order on a public interest petition filed by advocate Mansoor Ali Panhwar, seeking directives to authorities concerned particularly Sepa to assess water quality of Indus River around the Kotri Barrage, identify sources of pollution, including untreated sewage, hospital waste and industrial effluent, remedial measures and a comprehensive water quality protection and restoration plan.
The advocate argued that polluted water posed a serious threat to public health and environment.
The court, in its Nov 3 order, said that in view of serious nature of allegations and their direct bearing upon public health, environmental protection and fundamental rights, it had instructed AAG Sindh to ensure that a comprehensive and fact-based report was submitted by departments concerned.
The court incorporated in its order the points to be explicitly addressed in such a report.
The bench ordered that Sepa in coordination with relevant technical institutions, shall arrange collection and scientific testing of water samples from appropriate locations upstream and downstream of Kotri Barrage, including affected areas through a recognised laboratory and submit results reflecting relevant physical, chemical and microbiological parameters.
The court said authorities concerned shall identify and prepare an inventory of municipal drains, industrial outlets, hospitals and other sources discharging sewage, untreated effluent or waste into Indus and its connected watercourses within relevant area.
Sepa and concerned departments shall conduct joint inspections of suspected pollution sources, including industrial units, hospitals, municipal drains and sewage treatment facilities and identify entities responsible for any unlawful discharge.
The PHE and local government departments shall furnish details of existing sewerage and wastewater-treatment facilities, their operational status, deficiencies and measures required for their rehabilitation or improvement.
The court noted that wherever any discharge was found in violation of applicable environmental standards, Sepa shall take appropriate action in accordance with law, including issuance of statutory notices and directives and ensure that necessary measures were taken to prevent further unlawful discharge.
The authorities shall explain arrangements available for collection, treatment and safe disposal of hospital waste and industrial effluents and measures adopted to ensure compliance with applicable environmental laws.
It said respondents shall indicate a practical and time bound action plan for controlling identified sources of pollution, improving wastewater treatment facilities and protecting water quality of Indus River around Kotri Barrage with estimated financial requirements and responsible departments.
The court wanted authorities to identify any violations detected, responsible entities and enforcement action taken or proposed to be taken as per law.
The court also said the report shall be supported by relevant laboratory results, inspection reports, photographs, maps of identified outfalls and documentary evidence.
Authorities shall also indicate which remedial measures have already been undertaken and timeline for completing remaining measures.
The court had clarified that this exercise shall not remain confined to paper compliance and they shall take such immediate preventive measures as were warranted by findings without waiting for further orders of the court.