ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has accepted a set of appeals filed by the Capital Development Authority (CDA), challenging the Nov 18, 2025 order of the Islamabad High Court (IHC) in a case concerning compensation claims for land acquired for Sectors C-13 to C-16 in the capital.
While emphasising that CDA cannot invoke the finality of an award to evade its corresponding obligation, FCC explained that a subsisting award binds both the parties and cannot be disregarded merely because its consequences have become inconvenient.
‘The principle of finality binds the acquiring authority and the claimant alike,’ observed Chief Justice FCC Aminuddin Khan in a judgment he authored.
Headed by FCC chief justice with Justice Ali Baqar Najafi as its member, a two-judge bench allowed 25 CDA appeals while setting aside the Nov 18, 2025 IHC order of payment, plot allotment and market reassessment for affected landowners.
FCC also directed CDA to discharge verified, subsisting liabilities and determine additional compensation under section 32-A of the Capital Development Authority Ordinance 1960 upon fulfilment of its conditions. Possession and removal measures shall comply with statutory safeguards, while reminding that the concluded proceedings beyond this appeal remain unaffected, the FCC order said.
The controversy stemmed when a number of individuals approached IHC when their lands were acquired for Sectors C-13 to C-16 under the Dec 2, 2008 award and CDA’s land-sharing policy.
Alleging uncompensated dispossession and damage to built-up properties (BUPs), individuals sought compensation at prevailing market rates and inclusion of their structures in a new BUP award of Aug 17, 2023.
The high court disposed of twenty-five connected writ petitions and one contempt petition through Nov 18, 2025 consolidated judgment.
The consolidated judgment concerns compensation and rehabilitation claims arising from the acquisition of 14,944 kanals and 9 marlas in four revenue estates for Sectors C-13 to C-16, Islamabad.
The claimants had approached IHC alleging unpaid compensation, exclusion of structures, denial of rehabilitation benefits and unlawful demolition.
Consequently, CDA challenged IHC judgment before FCC on the grounds that post-acquisition structures were ineligible for compensation, statutory remedies were available, and the directions for reassessment and interest exceeded the governing statutory framework.
In its judgment FCC observed that the power of compulsory acquisition carries a corresponding duty to compensate those whose proprietary interests were acquired, adding Articles 4, 23 and 24 of the Constitution safeguard against arbitrary deprivation of property, while Article 10-A guarantees fair adjudication of disputed civil rights.
These guarantees require compensation in accordance with the law and do not empower the court to substitute a compensation mechanism of its own for that prescribed by the legislature.
The judicial intervention must rest upon an identifiable legal entitlement and a corresponding duty enforceable against the acquiring authority, Chief Justice FCC observed, adding that eligibility for BUP benefits must be established at the date prescribed by the governing award and rehabilitation scheme.
A subsequent survey may assist in reconstructing earlier conditions but cannot itself create entitlement arising from later construction, expansion or subdivision.
CDA relies on Dec 2,2008 as the cut-off date; its applicability and the existence and extent of any qualifying structure must be determined from the acquisition record, contemporaneous surveys, revenue entries, utility records and other reliable evidence.
The potentiality of the acquired property must be assessed as at the legally relevant valuation date; it cannot justify incorporating subsequent appreciation attributable to Islamabad’s development into a subsisting award.
Any omission of a legally relevant characteristic from the original assessment required challenge before the competent statutory forum. Re-assessment founded solely on the passage of time circumvents both the governing valuation rule and the prescribed remedies, FCC said.