Page 24 · Metro - Lahore

PA speaker demands clarity from PPP over division of provinces

LAHORE: Challenging his party’s ruling coalition partner, Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmed Khan on Wednesday questioned the Pakistan Peoples Party’s (PPP) policy of supporting the division of Punjab while vehemently opposing the bifurcation of Sindh, demanding that the party clarify its ideological and political contradictions.

Addressing a press conference at the Punjab Assembly, the speaker placed the most striking point of his address front and centre and said that while the Punjab Assembly unanimously passed a resolution for the division of Punjab, the PPP walked out the moment Sindh’s division was broached.

‘If a political party supports the division of one province while fiercely opposing another, it must explain the reason behind this double standard,’ Khan asserted, emphasising that discussing provincial reorganisation should not be treated as a taboo subject.

The speaker clarified that his earlier remarks regarding a referendum were intended to spark an institutional and public debate on why such measures become necessary, rather than serving as an immediate policy decree.

‘Referendums are a decision for political party leaderships, but the creation or alteration of provinces must ultimately be decided by assemblies,’ he noted. However, Khan maintained that the Constitution of Pakistan does not prohibit taking the public’s view, adding: ‘If the sovereign people of Pakistan -- who are the ultimate rulers after the Almighty -- reject a new province, no one can create it. Conversely, if they support it, provinces must be formed.’

He also pointed out that Article 48, Clause (3) of the Constitution provides clear procedural frameworks that warrant serious constitutional interpretation.

Shifting focus to recent statements by PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari regarding political prisoners and institutional crises, Khan drew a sharp line between legitimate political struggle and violent criminality.

‘How can burning down someone’s house be a political right?’ Khan asked, referencing the coordinated attacks on military installations. ‘Setting 29 cantonments on fire simultaneously is not a political right. If that is permitted today, Pakistan will no longer remain Pakistan,’ he said.

The speaker also addressed Bilawal’s observations about democratic system collapses, urging a transparent historical reckoning. He did not mince words regarding the country’s judicial and political history, declaring that the judicial execution of former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto remains the judiciary’s most egregious historical miscarriage of justice, while also acknowledging the heavy damage inflicted by past military dictators.

Stressing that he remains a staunch ally of the PPP and cannot work against them, Khan stressed that the ongoing discourse on administrative reform, resource distribution disparities between major and minor cities, governance, and devolution of power stems from civil society and must be addressed through mature, round-table political dialogue rather than parliamentary disruption.

‘We are citizens of Pakistan, and asking questions is our right,’ Khan said, adding that, ‘The PPP should sit down and talk, and at the very least, allow this vital conversation to continue.’