LAHORE: Opposition member in Punjab Assembly Rana Aftab Ahmad Khan has accused the Punjab government of using legislation as an instrument of absolute control rather than democratic consent.
In a letter to the Punjab Assembly speaker, PTI MPA from PP-108 Mr Khan said the entire legislative agenda of the government reflected one disturbing intention: ‘to govern through absolute control.’
The opposition MPA stated that every new law appeared designed not to empower institutions or protect citizens, but to strengthen the executive, centralise authority and suppress dissent.
Citing the Punjab Control of Habitual Offenders and Anti-Social Behaviour Bill and the expansion of administrative enforcement powers through Pera, Mr Khan said the pattern was unmistakable: ‘more for the government, fewer safeguards for the people’.
He said legislation was increasingly being used to convert political preferences into legal authority, giving executive decisions the appearance of constitutional legitimacy.
‘The government seems to have confused the rule of law with the rule by law. The former makes the government accountable to the law, the latter makes the law an instrument of government control,’ the letter stated.
Mr Khan alleged that bills were being rushed through the assembly, meaningful consultation was avoided, opposition objections were ignored, and parliamentary scrutiny was treated as an obstacle rather than a constitutional responsibility.
He said Articles 4, 10-A, 14, 16, 17 and 19 of the Constitution guarantee protection against arbitrary state action, fair trial, dignity, and freedom of assembly, association and expression, adding that these rights cannot be compromised through ordinary legislation.
‘A democratic government strengthens institutions; an authoritarian government makes institutions dependent on itself,’ he wrote. ‘A democratic government welcomes questions; an authoritarian government legislates against the possibility of being questioned.’
He warned that the province was witnessing a dangerous transition from institutional governance towards personalised executive authority, where every department, authority and enforcement mechanism was expected to operate according to the government’s political will.
‘If this government is confident in its performance, why does it need increasingly restrictive legislation? If it enjoys public confidence, why is dissent treated as a threat?’ Mr Khan asked.
‘You cannot legislate legitimacy, you cannot enforce public confidence, and you cannot manufacture consent through the fear of state power,’ he observed.
Clarifying the opposition’s position, he said the opposition was not against legislation, administrative reform or effective governance. ‘We are against laws that undermine constitutionalism, compromise fundamental rights and eliminate institutional checks and balances,’ he added.
He reminded the House that its constitutional responsibility was not to endorse executive decisions but to scrutinise, question and hold the government accountable.
‘The purpose of legislation in a democracy is to limit the exercise of power, not to legalise its exercise,’ he said and stressed that the House be allowed to make laws for the protection of citizens, not for the protection of those in power.