KARACHI: The Sindh High Court on Thursday directed the authorities concerned to immediately stop the ongoing construction and development activities at the Nehr-i-Khayyam in Clifton.
A two-judge constitutional bench of the SHC comprising Justice Riazat Ali Sahar and Justice Muhammad Hasan Akber also asked its office to communicate this order to the Sindh chief secretary, the Local Government (LG) Department secretary and the director general of Karachi Development Authority for compliance.
Residents of the area, along with local leaders of a political party, have petitioned the SHC and challenged the ongoing construction and development activities being carried out in and around Nehr-i-Khayyam and raising serious concerns about the preservation of the natural waterway.
Earlier, the SHC had issued notices to the Sindh chief secretary, LG department secretary, Karachi Metropolitan Corporation, KDA and other respondents on two identical petitions.
When the matter came up for hearing on Thursday, the bench noted that these were pro bono petitions filed by the citizens of Karachi, bringing to the court’s attention the alleged illegal construction over Nehr-i-Khayyam, which served as a storm water drainage channel.
It also stated that, as per the lawyers for the petitioners, the issue in question has already been considered by the Supreme Court, which had handed down a detailed judgement reported as 2020 SCMR 513. Despite specific directions issued by the SC, illegal construction was still being carried out over the waterway.
‘They, therefore, request that the secretary, local government department, government of Sindh, and the Karachi Development Authority, respondents No.2 and respondents No.4 respectively, be directed to immediately stop such illegal construction till the next date of hearing. Order accordingly’, it added.
Adjourning the hearing till Jan 18, 2027, the bench further said, ‘Let a copy of this order be communicated to the chief secretary, government of Sindh, secretary local government and director general Karachi Development Authority for compliance’.
Initially, Ava Ardeshir Cowasjee had approached the SHC and submitted that, as a resident of Bath Island, she was directly affected by the actions of the respondents.
The petitioner argued that, in pursuance of the provisions of the Karachi Development Authority Order 1957, the KDA had planned the area known as KDA Scheme No.5, providing therein for an amenity space being a canal/storm drain which was to be known as Nehr-i-Khayyam and the same was demarcated and shown in the master plan, including two roads on either side which has been officially published.
She also asserted that the waterway and the roads abutting the strip of land were required for the maintenance and servicing of the Nehr-i-Khayyam and were part and parcel of the same. She said many attempts had been made in the past to construct commercial buildings on the subject land, but these had been stopped following directives of the judiciary, and now, the ongoing construction had started in the first week of last month.
The petitioner further maintained that the ongoing activities were not confined to the maintenance, clearing or improvement of the storm-water drain, but involved changing its use and introducing commercial recreational activities along it.
The other petition was filed by the City Council Opposition Leader, Advocate Saifuddin, along with deputy parliamentary leader Taimoor Ahmed and two residents of the area concerned. They asserted that they were aggrieved by the ongoing construction activities being carried out in and around the waterway, including adjacent amenity plots, which had raised serious concerns about the preservation of the natural waterway, the potential adverse impact upon the city’s rainwater drainage system and the possible commercial utilisation of land of such waterway.
They also argued that the construction, alteration and development were being carried out rapidly on the subject waterway and the mega project was being proceeded without a proper technical and environmental assessment, which may adversely affect the flow of rainwater, particularly during the monsoon season, thereby endangering public safety and the civic interests of residents of Karachi.
They further contended that the respondents could not reduce the width of the waterway, disregard the approved planning framework or permit development inconsistent with the designated purpose of the watercourse and its associated public infrastructure.
Referring to previous judgements of the SC and the SHC, the petitioners maintained that the judiciary had stopped the construction in the vicinity of Nehr-i-Khayyam on several occasions, but after reported suspension of construction for a brief period, such activities had time and again been resumed.
The petitioners maintained that if these construction activities were allowed to continue without lawful authority, adequate technical assessment and compliance with the applicable environmental safeguards, the same would threaten the effective functioning of an essential storm-water drainage facility and expose the residents to risks of flooding and environmental degradation.
They pleaded to declare as illegal the alleged conversion, alteration or utilisation of the storm-water drain into a recreational park or commercial venture or any other inconsistent purpose without lawful authority and compliance with the applicable laws.
The petitioners also sought directives for the respondents to immediately halt all ongoing construction and development activities and remove all structures, encroachments, unauthorised constructions, reclaimed portions and other works already erected or undertaken within the lawful boundaries of Nehr-i-Khayyam.
They further asked the court to preserve Nehr-i-Khayyam for its lawful purpose and primary function as a storm-water drainage channel.