Page 7 · Opinion

Unsafe schools

THIS is with reference to the editorial ‘Deadly classrooms’ (Oct 16) about the school roof collapse in Peshawar which resulted in the deaths of 30 students and a female teacher. The tragedy exposed poor governance, weak oversight and a serious failure by the government that was ruling Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) at the time. A school should be a place of learning and security, not one where children risk their lives. Tragedies demand accountability.

What happened in Peshawar is not a problem confined to KP alone. The plight of school infrastructure is concerning in Sindh as well. According to figures reported in March, the 2022 floods damaged 19,808 schools across the province, of which 14,343 were still awaiting restoration.

In August 2026, it was reported that 93 school buildings in Larkana district had been declared dangerous, affecting approximately 5,230 students. These figures highlight the need to assess building conditions, complete outstanding repairs and protect students from unsafe premises.

Provincial governments should carry out regular structural inspections of every public and private school by qualified engineers. Buildings declared unsafe must be evacuated until repairs are completed and their safety is independently certified. Where closure is necessary, the authorities should arrange safe temporary classrooms so that the students do not lose access to education.

Governments must also publish district-wise inspection data, allocate dedicated maintenance funds and establish deadlines for repairing all dangerous buildings. Independent investigations should identify the causes of collapses, while owners, contractors and officials should face legal consequences wherever negligence is established. Parents and teachers should have convenient, accessible channels to report structural hazards, with complaints investigated promptly.

Most importantly, the authorities must prioritise prevention over reaction. A transparent monitoring system, routine maintenance and independent safety certification would help identify risks before they become fatal. The cost of these measures cannot reasonably outweigh the human cost of preventable deaths.

Every child deserves the right to learn in a safe environment. School safety must become a basic public responsibility. It should not be a concern addressed only post-event. The real measure of government actions is not how many inquiries are announced after a collapse, but how many lives it protects before a tragedy strikes.

Ghulam Mustafa Soomro

Jacobabad