Page 19 · Metro - Islamabad

Court extends physical remand of accused in minor maid’s murder case

ISLAMABAD: A local judicial magistrate on Friday extended the physical remand of both the accused in the case of torturing a 13-year-old domestic worker to death by another three days, while directing the investigating officer to broaden the scope of the probe to determine whether the child was subjected to bonded labour and exploitation.

Judicial Magistrate Naima Iffat issued the written order extending the remand of the accused in the murder case of Fatima Asghar. The police had initially sought a four-day extension, but the court granted three days.

During the proceedings, Deputy District Prosecutor Wajid Munir informed the court that the post-mortem report revealed 20 injuries on the child’s body. The prosecutor argued that the presence of older wounds indicated a sustained pattern of abuse, adding that the child was never provided with medical treatment.

The prosecution further informed the court that an electric iron had been recovered from the female accused and a stick from the male accused. According to the prosecutor, the victim was burned with the electric iron.

The court was also told that the Digital Video Recorder (DVR) containing CCTV footage of the incident had been sent for forensic analysis, and the footage clearly showed the child being subjected to repeated acts of violence.

The prosecution requested permission to conduct polygraph and voice-matching tests to ascertain the specific role of a third suspect. When the magistrate inquired about the data retention of the DVR, the investigating officer (IO) stated it contained seven days’ worth of footage.

The court subsequently directed that the relevant videos be made part of the record and that screenshots, stored on a USB drive, be attached to the case file. The defence counsel argued that the child had been treated as a family member and that since most of the evidence had already been recovered, further physical remand was unnecessary.

The defence further claimed that the case was effectively being decided during the remand hearing and alleged an evident display of hostility toward the accused. In its written order, the court noted that while the FIR states the complainant, the child’s father, handed her over to the accused family three years ago for education, the record lacked material to verify this claim.

‘Record shows that the case is registered under Section 302 PPC. The medical evidence prima facie indicates that the deceased sustained multiple injuries and died allegedly as a consequence of physical torture,’ the order read.

The court observed that the gap in the record regarding the alleged relationship and the actual purpose of the handover supports the IO’s plea for further time to investigate. The investigating officer revealed that the husband of the female accused and the child’s father are maternal cousins, and that the child had been living in the household for three years, playing with the other children and performing tasks for the female accused.

Magistrate Iffat directed the IO to determine the exact age of the deceased at the time she was handed over by collecting reliable documentary evidence, including Nadra records and birth registration.

The court also ordered the IO to verify the alleged relationship between the complainant and the accused family, and to ascertain whether any actual arrangement regarding her education, maintenance, or welfare was made.

Furthermore, the court directed an inquiry into whether the child was engaged in domestic work or employed in any capacity, including any child labour or exploitation. The IO was instructed to examine the circumstances under which the child was brought to the official residence of the female accused’s husband, and to assess his knowledge of her presence, her treatment, and his individual liability based on evidence.

The court also ordered the IO to investigate the circumstances under which the complainant entrusted his minor daughter to the household. The IO must determine whether the father received any financial consideration or benefit, and whether he knowingly permitted her engagement in domestic work, with his potential involvement under Section 328-A PPC to be examined, it observed.

The court explicitly directed the IO to consider the applicability of Sections 328 and 328-A of the Pakistan Penal Code, along with Section 3 of the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act, 2022.