Page 4 · National

Court offers to resolve dispute between PTI MNA, minister

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) on Monday offered to resolve dispute between Pakistan Tehrik-i-Insaf (PTI) lawmaker Dr Shireen Mazari and the defence minister, Khawaja Mohammad Asif.

IHC division bench comprising Justice Shaukat Aziz Siddiqui and Justice Mohsin Akhtar Kayani on Monday admitted an intra court appeal (ICA) filed by Dr Mazari seeking action against the minister for passing derogatory remarks against her on the floor of the National Assembly.

The bench asked the counsel for both Dr Mazari and Asif to bring their clients on Dec 8 when the court would resume hearing of the case.

However, the bench in its written order did not mention any direction related to the summoning of the politicians as the order simply mentioned the next date when the court would take up the appeal again.

Dr Mazari sought IHC’s intervention to create an exception in Article 69 and reinterpret its provision for the protection of women on the floor of the National Assembly.

While challenging a single bench order, Dr Mazari, through her counsel Barrister Shoaib Razzaq, filed an ICA, seeking reinterpretation of the law. She linked it to Federal Minister for Defence Khawaja Asif’s derogatory remarks against her during a session of the lower house in June.

Earlier, Justice Athar Minallah dismissed her petition, which sought the disqualification of the defence minister over his remarks.

Mazari cited federation as respondent through Minister for Law and Justice Zahid Hamid, Minister for Defence and Water & Power Khawaja Asif, Speaker of the National Assembly Ayaz Sadiq and the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs through federal minister Sheikh Aftab Ahmed.

Her counsel Barrister Shoaib Razzaq stated that Asif, while pointing towards Mazari, made an insulting comment when she and other lawmakers were protesting against his speech on load-shedding during Ramazan.

‘The impugned remarks were a malicious attempt to harass and intimidate the appellant and impede her from scrutinising the law,’ he stated. He added that Mazari’s fundamental rights had been violated and no effective relief was provided to her.

The counsel said Asif made derogatory remarks against the petitioner and this was seen by millions on television. The footage is still available on certain social media forums.

He claimed the remarks were criminal in nature as Asif defamation of Mazari falls under Section 500 of the Pakistan PenalCode,1860.

‘We have rights for women in every corner of the law.

We have created special provisions, statuses and even reserved seats for them in the assembly. Ironically, the same women who vehemently fought for the Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Worl(place Act, 2010 were failed by the archaic interpretation and implementation of Article 69.

He argued the petitioner did not want to unintentionally challenge the sanctity of parliament or become a hindrance to legislatures when it comes to their work.

Mazari has requested the court to create an exception in Article 69 and reinterpret its provision for the protection of women on the floor.