PREVIOUSLY, the line separating the ruling parties and the opposition was quite clearly defined. Very quickly, it has become rather blurred. The possibility of an administrative restructuring of the state apparatus seems to have jolted the status quo. The past week saw things come almost to a head between the PML-N and the PPP after the PPP chairman minced no words in spelling out his party’s opposition to any move to split the provinces. In response, several PML-N leaders took a defiant tone while expressing direct or indirect support for the idea of new provinces. In the political backdrop was the JUI-F’s recent, rather ugly run-in with the government, as well as the curious, if rather minor, turnabout in the PTI’s fortunes that triggered speculation over a possible ‘deal’.
Over the course of the week, the PPP seemed to be in two minds about the future. On the one hand, Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari floated the idea of a fresh election within six months instead of a referendum on new provinces. Later, he said he wants Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to be the first prime minister to complete a five-year term. Mr Bhutto-Zardari also conceded at one point that neither a referendum nor a fresh election could be held before electoral reforms. Clearly, while he has some ideas, he does not have a viable way out of the current conundrum. On the other hand, the PML-N’s parliamentary affairs minister insisted that a referendum ‘will happen’ and that his party would make every effort to bring the PPP round to the idea. The defence minister also echoed that sentiment, while the information minister backed a referendum if the public also supported it. The PM has yet to make his position publicly known.
Elsewhere, the PTI’s chief whip said recently that he backed a referendum to gauge public opinion on new provinces, but added that the final decision will rest with the party’s jailed founder. The party chairman, on the other hand, said it was premature to comment on the idea. Either the PTI itself is unsure about its options, or is deliberately maintaining strategic ambiguity to gain some leverage. From a different perspective, the political parties that control most of the votes in parliament are engaged in a Mexican standoff. They cannot decide the country’s future like this. Given where things stand, a fresh election may seem like a good idea. Perhaps, instead of endlessly debating the idea of new provinces, all efforts should be directed at making possible an election that is free, fair and conducted without any interference. The referendum can be made part of the same exercise. Whichever party wins the election should then be bound to implement the public’s will. This seems to be the best way forward.