Page 7 · Opinion

Whose trauma?

THE first time I heard the phrase ‘lived experience,’ I was sitting in a graduate school seminar in 2017. A classmate used it to end an argument. Her experience was lived. Others’, apparently, was not, or at least not in the way that counted. I remember thinking: what does that even mean? What other experience is there?

Then came the trigger warnings. Before we even got to university, we were sent messages about how certain readings might upset us and we could opt out of reading them, even attending that lecture. We were offered space to step out, to take care of ourselves, to process. Trauma was everywhere in that classroom, and it was handled gently.

Except, I noticed, when it came from somewhere else. Anyone from the Global South or Muslim, for example, was not entitled to the same level of care accorded to the majority, usually privileged. To clarify, care for us seemed real and perhaps even was sincere. It just didn’t travel very far. Our histories were material for discussion. Theirs were wounds to be protected.

I have been thinking about that classroom again because of the debate around a book I haven’t read yet.

Catherine Liu’s Traumatised: The New Politics of Public Suffering has set off discussions I have been following for weeks, in podcast clips, interviews and reviews. Which may, in itself, prove her point.

Liu, a professor at the University of California argues that trauma, once a clinical term for the aftermath of real violence, has become a kind of currency for the professional class: academics, journalists, therapists, NGO workers, even people like me. Presenting trauma as something everyone shares, she says, makes it easier to ignore the suffering that comes from poverty and exploitation, and to replace the hard work of politics with the softer work of recognition.

You don’t have to agree with all of it to recognise what she is describing. The word is everywhere. Students use it to ask for extensions. Employees use it to describe a difficult meeting. Celebrities use it to sell memoirs. I am not mocking anyone who is genuinely suffering. But a word stretched this far loses its shape. And a culture that rewards the word will get more of it.

Liu traces part of that reward back to a moment in 1986 when Oprah Winfrey told her TV audience she had been sexually abused as a child. It was a brave moment, and it helped many women speak about what had happened to them. But it also did something else. It made pain into a brand. In Liu’s words, televised confession turned private trauma into ‘spectacle, content, and commodity all at once.’ Oprah went on to build the most successful daytime talk show in history, and an empire.

Oprah needed a network. Today, all anyone needs is a phone. The confession is now a format, and every platform is a studio. Share your story, own your truth, grow your following. The platforms profit either way.

So who gets rewarded when they say the word? Usually those with a platform, a polished story and the right audience. Those who know the language. Those whose pain is legible to the people listening.

Which brings me to Gaza.

For more than two years, Palestinians have recorded their own suffering, live, on their phones, for the whole world to see. Children pulled from rubble. Parents writing their children’s names on their arms. By any measure, they have the strongest claim to the word. And yet what they meet is so often doubt, fatigue or silence. Their footage is questioned. Their numbers are disputed. Their grief is treated as propaganda.

Even Liu’s critics have noticed the gap. One reviewer pointed out that in her book about public suffering, the word ‘Palestinian’ appears just once, in a citation from the 1990s.

This is what bothers me most. Not that the word has been stretched, but who it has been stretched for. The comfortable can call a deadline traumatic and be met with sympathy. The rest of us who are bombed are asked to prove it.

Liu’s argument is about class. Mine is about geography too. The same care that was offered so gently in my graduate seminar has never quite reached the people from where I come from, or from Gaza, Sudan or the Congo. Our suffering is news. Theirs is trauma.

None of this means we should stop using the word. Trauma is real, and so is the need to talk about it. But perhaps we should ask, each time we hear it, what it is being used for, and who is being left out.

If the word can stretch to cover a missed deadline, why can’t it reach a bombed street?

Maybe the question was never whose trauma. It was always whose word. ■

The writer is a journalist and conducts writing workshops in Karachi.

X: @LedeingLady