Page 10 · International

Fossil fuel dispute threatens to scupper climate deal

ANTALYA: A fight over fossil fuels threatened to derail UN climate talks on Saturday as nations pushed back against a proposed agreement that scrapped any mention of planet-heating coal, oil and gas. Negotiations dragged into extra time after the summit in Turkiye sailed past Friday’s scheduled closing time, with talks through the night failing to break the impasse.

COP31 co-hosts Australia and Turkiye are scrambling to produce a revised draft deal as time runs out and delegates prepare to leave after two weeks of exhaustive negotiations. ‘Getting bogged down in individual words and expressions and undermining this process serves no one’s interests,’ said COP31 President and Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum, who urged countries to ‘act responsibly’ and compromise.

Expectations of a major breakthrough in the Turkish city of Antalya have been low as countries grapple with an oil price shock and geopolitical tensions stemming from the war in Iran. The summit follows a string of climate-linked disasters from Europe to Nepal and Indonesia and unfolds as a super El Nino pattern amplifies the risk of further extreme weather.

A draft climate deal unveiled earlier this week called for a faster phase-out of fossil fuels but a second, pared-down version released Thursday stripped away all mentions of coal, oil and gas.

‘Red lines’

Fossil fuels are the main driver of climate change but a flashpoint at the UN talks. Their omission from the draft sparked protests and threats to walk away from the table. ‘That is a red line for us. We’re talking about the root cause of all of this,’ Tuvalu’s Climate Minister Maina Talia told reporters.

Talia, whose low-lying Pacific nation is threatened by rising sea levels, said if the world cannot address fossil fuels ‘then we are wasting our time here’. When asked if divisions over fossil fuels and carbon capture technology could be bridged, European Union climate envoy Wopke Hoekstra said: ‘Clearly there’s no compromise yet.’ ‘It’s better to have no deal than to have a bad deal,’ he told reporters.

Ireland’s Climate Minister Darragh O’Brien said there were around ‘130 countries at this COP who want — at the very least — a reference to fossil fuel and phase-out’ in the final text.

A call to ramp up carbon capture — a contentious technology championed by the fossil fuel industry — in the last draft also faced staunch opposition. Critics point to its high cost and meagre record in cutting emissions, warning it risks prolonging fossil fuel use.

‘There are several fights but the primary one is still the one between mostly the EU and Saudi Arabia’ over fossil fuels and carbon capture, said Li Shuo, an analyst from the Asia Society Policy Institute. A dozen European and developing countries — from France to Panama and the Solomon Islands — released a letter Friday insisting that the deal include ‘a clear transition away from fossil fuels’.

Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, accused a ‘petroleum mafia’ of blocking progress and threatened to walk away from the talks unless a stronger deal was made. Meanwhile, the OPEC oil cartel wrote on X that its head, Haitham Al Ghais, had met with Russian presidential climate envoy Ruslan Edelgeriev at COP31 on Friday.—AFP