Page 15 · Metro - Karachi

FIA probe sought into ‘issuance of fraudulent domiciles’ in Sindh

KARACHI: Senior Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan leader Khawaja Izharul Hasan has asked the federal interior minister to issue an immediate directive to the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) for holding a sample-based inquiry into the issuance of alleged fraudulent domicile certificates in the province.

He said deputy commissioners and other officers in Sindh had been issuing the certificates only as delegates under federal law and rules, and proposed that the National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) be authorised to issue domicile certificates to rectify the problem at its source.

He also sought formation of a special inquiry team of FIA at the provincial metropolis to investigate such domicile certificates issued from January 2024 to date, to collect and preserve the entire record from every DC office across the province.

Mr Hasan, a senior party leader and an MNA from Karachi, has also filed an appeal before the Supreme Court after the Sindh High Court had turned down his petition in May 2023 filed against issuance of domiciles and permanent residence certificates (PRCs) to non-residents of Karachi.

In a letter, addressing the minister for interior & narcotics control, the MNA, who is also a practising lawyer, has sought directives for the director general of FIA to begin an immediate sample-based inquiry into domicile certificates issued in Sindh under the Pakistan Citizenship Act, 1951 and the Pakistan Citizenship Rules, 1952.

By separate letter of even date, the lawmaker said he has also proposed that Nadra be authorised to issue domicile certificates so that the problem is cured at its source.

‘Credible reports and public complaints indicate that domicile certificates are being issued in large numbers, on a daily basis, to persons who do not meet the conditions of the law. These include persons with no qualifying residence in Sindh, persons already holding domicile of another province or area, and in some cases persons who may not be citizens of Pakistan at all,’ he stated.

The consequences reach beyond one province as he further maintained that a domicile certificate determined a candidate’s provincial and regional share in the federal services under Article 27(1) and Article 38(g) of the Constitution and Rule 14 of the Civil Servants (Appointment, Promotion and Transfer) Rules, 1973.

The letter said: ‘It also governs admissions, scholarships and Sindh’s own urban and rural allocations. Every fraudulent certificate takes a seat from a lawful domiciliary. Where an alien obtains one, it is also a matter of national security.’

Mr Hasan argued that a domicile certificate was a federal instrument under Section 17 of the Pakistan Citizenship Act and the certificate may be granted only where applicant has ordinarily resided for at least one year immediately before applying and has in fact acquired a domicile.

He also said in the letter, ‘Deputy commissioners and other officers in Sindh issue these certificates only as delegates, under Section 18 of the Act and Rule 23 of the Pakistan Citizenship Rules, 1952. Rule 29 provides that everything done by such officers or by the provincial government under the rules is deemed to be done by or on behalf of the federal government. Responsibility for the integrity of every domicile certificate issued in Sindh therefore rests, in law, with the federal government. Within the federal government, it rests with the ministry of interior, which administers citizenship, the FIA, Nadra and the directorate general of immigration and passports’. Regarding further authority of the federal government on the subject matter, the MQM-P leader further said that Rule 30 empowered the federal government, at any time, to cancel, suspend, invalidate or revise any certificate issued under such rules and under Section 21 of the Act and Rule 26 a false statement made to obtain a certificate was an offence and allowing federal government to authorise police investigation and prosecution under Sections 155 Criminal Procedure Code and 177 Pakistan Penal Code respectively while a conviction rendered such certificate null and void.

The federal authorities concerned were also sanctioned under Section 16(2) of the law to deprive citizenship where it rested on a domicile certificate obtained by fraud, false representation or concealment of a material fact, he added.

The MNA in his letter also referred to the FIA Act, 1974, saying that it has placed superintendence of FIA in federal government and its schedule has also covered the offences in question apart from the PPC, the Prevention of Corruption Act 1947, the Foreigners Act, 1946, and the National Database and Registration Authority Ordinance, 2000.

He further said: ‘A full audit of every certificate would take years. A properly drawn sample will show quickly whether the problem is isolated or systemic, how large it is, and who is responsible’.

He asked the ministry to direct the DG FIA to constitute a special inquiry team at Karachi to probe the matter in question after obtaining the entire record from every DC office of the province, including domicile issuance registers, Form ‘P’, affidavits and supporting documents for certificates issued from January 2024 to date as well as preservation of such record from alteration or damage.

Mr Hasan also suggested that a random sample be collected from each district of not less than five per cent of certificates issued or 200 certificates and target the samples, including those with unusually high issuance on a single day or by a single officer, or applicants whose Nadra permanent address lies outside Karachi, whose address was changed shortly before the application and applicants who get government job or admissions in the public universities of Karachi immediately after getting domicile & PRCs.

He further recommended that during the proposed probe, the verification of applicant’s Nadra record, family tree, claim of one-year residence, authenticity of utility bills, tenancy or ownership documents, school records, any PRC relied upon, affidavit as required by Rule 23(a) and applicant’s citizenship status must be carried out.

The investigation may also identify the recommending and issuing officers, any agents or touts involved and any payments made to obtain such certificate and the probe report should contain the proportion of irregular certificates found in each district of the metropolis, the MNA concluded in his letter.