Page 16 · Metro - Karachi

Country’s resources, policies favour privileged groups

Economists, business leaders call for structural reforms to address economic inequalities

KARACHI: Economists and business leaders on Saturday called for structural reforms in taxation, agriculture, education and public spending to address economic inequalities in Pakistan, arguing that the country’s resources and policies continued to favour privileged groups at the expense of the poor.

They were speaking at a seminar titled ‘Breaking the Paradox of Elite Capture: Subsidising the Rich and Borrowing to Feed the Poor’, organised by the Pakistan Women’s Foundation for Peace (PWFFP) at the Pakistan American Cultural Centre (PACC).

The event brought together Dr Ishrat Husain, former governor of the State Bank of Pakistan; Ehsan Malik, former CEO of Unilever Pakistan and the Pakistan Business Council; and Dr Asad Sayeed, director of the Collective for Social Science Research. Students and faculty members from universities also attended the seminar.

In her introductory address, PWFFP Chairperson Nargis Rahman said the organisation had taken up the issue of the economy after witnessing widespread poverty, hunger, disease, unemployment, crime and a lack of civic services and access to justice during visits to low-income settlements in Karachi.

She said visits to universities had also revealed anxiety among students, particularly those from middle-class families, about employment opportunities and the lack of merit recognition.

Explaining the concept of elite capture, Ms Rahman said it had its roots in the era of Dr Mahbub ul Haq’s ‘22 families’. Today, she said, a small group controlled wealth, power and borrowing across generations and could influence the laws of the state.

She noted that the International Monetary Fund had described Pakistan’s situation as ‘state capture’.

Citing the UNDP’s National Human Development Report 2020, she said privileges enjoyed by powerful groups amounted to about Rs2,660 billion in 2017-18, equivalent to roughly seven per cent of GDP. In comparison, social protection cost Rs624bn in 2019. The report found that redirecting just 24pc of these privileges towards the poor could double their benefits.

Ms Rahman highlighted the differing estimates of poverty in the country, saying official data put the rate at 28.9pc, Continued on Page 14 while the Social Policy and Development Centre estimated it at 43.5pc and the World Bank indicated that about 45pc of the population lived below the lower-middle-income poverty benchmark.

She added that child stunting affected 40-44pc of children under five nationally, rising to 57pc in the poorest quintile. Pakistan ranked 106th out of 122 countries on the Global Hunger Index and 168th out of 193 on the Human Development Index.

Pointing to what she described as the paradox of elite capture, Ms Rahman said programmes for the poor, including the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP), were financed through tax revenue and borrowing, while privileges enjoyed by powerful groups remained largely untouched.

Dr Ishrat Husain, author of Pakistan: The Economy of an Elitist State, said the revised edition had allowed him to review developments in the country over two decades. The term ‘elite capture’, he noted, had not been widely used in Pakistan until around 2010.

He argued that economic growth and poverty reduction were closely linked, as higher growth helped reduce unemployment and poverty and improve livelihoods.

He said countries such as South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, China and Indonesia had adopted a model of shared growth in which its benefits reached the wider population. Pakistan, in contrast, had followed an elite-driven model involving political leaders, senior civil and military officers, industrialists and religious leaders, a group whose size continued to expand.

While markets could allocate resources efficiently and support economic growth, they could not ensure equitable distribution, particularly for disadvantaged groups, he said. In Pakistan, the state had been hijacked and the market rigged by the same class, he added, describing this as the core problem that needed to be addressed.

Dr Husain proposed six measures to dismantle the existing model: devolving legal, administrative and fiscal powers to local governments; reviving agriculture, particularly small farming, through credit and support; reforming university education to equip graduates with marketable skills; expanding financial inclusion to support low-cost housing, young professionals and small and medium enterprises; reforming fiscal policy; and increasing investment in human development.

Call for improved tax efficiency

Ehsan Malik focused on taxation and protection, referring to the 2020 UNDP report that estimated elite privileges at about Rs2.7 trillion. He contrasted this with the roughly Rs800bn spent on BISP this year.

He said Pakistan had about 3.5 million taxpayers, with the top one per cent contributing around 80pc of income tax. The tax system, he added, was driven by short-term revenue requirements rather than a medium- or long-term policy framework.

Mr Malik said about 33pc of income tax was collected through advance and withholding taxes, while approximately 35pc of revenue was collected at the import stage. Although salaried people paid tax every month, only about ‘eight per cent of income tax was actually recovered by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR)’, he said, suggesting that parts of tax administration could be outsourced.

He called for a higher tax-to-GDP ratio and improved tax efficiency, arguing that agriculture, undeclared taxpayers, wholesalers, transporters and the real estate sector either did not contribute or contributed too little. Meanwhile, sales tax was also paid by people who barely earned enough to meet their living expenses.

He outlined six priorities for addressing elite capture: dismantling the system, breaking intergenerational poverty, creating productive livelihoods, adopting new technologies and understanding their impact, empowering women and reducing provincial and district-level inequalities, particularly at the district level.

Dr Asad Sayeed questioned who actually benefited from government subsidies, examining the federal budget’s allocation of funds.

He said the total subsidy bill stood at about Rs1.1 trillion, excluding BISP. Of this amount, Rs133bn went to poorer regions, including erstwhile Fata, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Azad Kashmir and tubewells in Balochistan.

About Rs700bn was allocated to electricity subsidies, he said, questioning who benefited most from the spending. He also pointed to inequalities in the energy sector, including depreciation and payment shortfalls in several regions.

Dr Sayeed said some subsidies directly benefited better-off groups, citing the Prime Minister’s Apna Ghar scheme.

A substantial portion of public spending also went to the middle class, he said, pointing to the Rs2 trillion spent on pensions for government employees and benefits such as pension eligibility for unmarried daughters of deceased government servants.

He argued that despite substantial public spending, poverty continued to rise because the economy lacked growth.

The seminar was opened by PWFFP President Michiko Adil, who said the discussion was ultimately about people, their dignity, livelihoods and aspirations.