Page 31 · Icon

FRESH LEGS FOR SCROOGE TALE

Often in the right when it comes to trailers, this writer relishes the opportunity to be proven wrong when the actual film turns out to be quite a bit better.

Case in point: Ebenezer — yet another of the hundreds of film, TV and streaming adaptations of Charles Dickens’ Christmas novella A Christmas Carol, where an unkind, stingy old man is visited by the spirits of the past, present and future that violently shake the ‘Bah! Humbug!’ out of him.

This time, Ebenezer Scrooge is played by Johnny Depp (who is also a producer) in a role that — one is surprised — he hasn’t done before. The quirkily macabre horror setting fits naturally into a Tim Burton film, so imagine another surprise when the director (and also the co-editor) turns out to be Ti West (The Innkeepers, the ‘X’ Trilogy). Surprise, surprise then, because West turns out to be a better director than Tim Burton of late.

Homing in on the ‘classic’ mindset of movies, with an assured directorial hand that makes you feel that you’re watching a film from the mid-to-late 1990s, West lets the material, the production design (by Eve Stewart) and Depp do the heavy lifting.

Nathaniel Halpern’s screenplay is mostly a straight adaptation of this time-travel story (as director Robert Zemeckis put it when he made his own version with Jim Carrey), about Ebenezer (Johnny Depp, in excellent form) who is all but forced into kindness by the ghost of his former business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) and the three spirits — the Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough), the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and the hooded, floating Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come (Robert Strange).

By the end of his nightmare trip across time, he appreciates and grows close to his nephew, Fred, and his wife, Clara (Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley) and makes up for his mistreatment of his good-spirited clerk Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), whose son, Tiny Tim (Freddie Lee-Grey), is handicapped and has a debilitating illness.

Dickens, if anything, has never been subtle in his portrayal of black-and-white: the bad would look bad physically, as if their crooked inner selves were reflected in their visages, and the poor would have the worst of circumstances. Much the same stays true in this adaptation.

However, there are some minor creative deviations. They fit well within the film’s dark buildings and unforgiving, cold, snowy feel. For example: Dickens wrote the Ghost of Christmas Past as an ‘it’, making the gender ambiguous, while its form shifted between young and old. Here, the ‘it’ has been turned into a woman spectre, with hollow cheekbones, retina-less eyes, draped in white, who accentuates the horror aspect of the story.

This and other welcome changes, such as Marley’s extended introduction — which most versions don’t show — and scenes with Fred, Clara and Bob Cratchit’s family, help viewers sympathise with Ebenezer as he becomes a better man.

Dickens’ story is a fine old Christmas tale meant to shake one’s conscience, that has been made into a fine new film by West that keeps your belief in cinema alive. Given the way movies are being made, I suppose that is the real Christmas miracle. ■

Released internationally by Paramount Pictures and in Pakistan by HKC Entertainment, Ebenezer is rated PG for light scares, courtesy of Scrooge’s past, present and future misdeeds.

The writer is Icon’s primary film reviewer