Page 6 · Editorial

Settling disputes

WITH almost 2m court cases clogging the lower judiciary — most of them in Punjab — Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz’s nod to a proposed panchayat system to resolve local-level disputes is expected to be well received by many litigants. Several factors are responsible for a situation in which disputing parties often find themselves waiting for decades before their cases are settled. A shortage of judges, unclear rules, frequent court adjournments, and corruption at all tiers are just a few of the underlying causes. It is no wonder then that informal forums of ‘justice’, based more on centuries-old, often barbaric customs than on modern legal principles, persist in the country. Seen in this light, a panchayat system that prioritises community decision-making but with some state regulation, appears, at least theoretically, to be the right move. However, as with any initiative, it is important to closely study similar local justice schemes elsewhere before embarking on the proposed project. For instance, India’s village justice court system aimed at providing inexpensive and accessible justice to rural communities in the country, has had mixed results that should provide a useful clue for the government here. In fact, Pakistan is no stranger to alternative dispute resolution laws intended to reduce the burden on the courts. The Punjab Alternative Dispute Resolution Act, 2019 — recently repealed by the Punjab Alternative Dispute Resolution Ordinance, 2026 — is a case in point. The ‘success’ of the repealed law can justifiably be questioned. How will the proposed panchayat framework ensure better results?

It is too early to be ambitious. Small steps towards the larger goal of an integrated justice system will allow the authorities to ensure accessible legal relief for Pakistan’s rural communities — measures that are sensitive to local concerns without straying from constitutional norms. Above all, there can be no further dillydallying on reforms that strengthen the judicial system — judicial slots must be filled, procedures simplified, and corruption reined in.