I HAVE often wondered what makes it so difficult for a government officer to say no. A straightforward refusal, accompanied by a reason, would command far more respect than the elaborate exercise in silence, evasion and false assurances that passes for official communication in much of our bureaucracy.
My recent encounters with the Sindh Culture Department have offered a revealing lesson in this peculiar art of non-communication.
For several weeks, I have been attempting to organise free dance-theatre performances across Sindh, taking high-quality productions to towns where opportunities to experience storytelling on stage are scarce. We would bring the artists, bear production and technical costs and arrange the performances. All we sought was access to public cultural venues.
One might imagine that a department entrusted with promoting culture would welcome such an initiative. Instead, I encountered unanswered messages, unreturned calls and unfulfilled promises.
First, I struggled with departmental officers and came back with nothing. Then I tried securing a meeting with the culture minister through conventional channels. His secretary and various officials passed me endlessly from one number to another. Eventually, his secretary blocked my persistent coordinator’s number. This young man has perfected a particularly ingenious form of communication. While a WhatsApp call to him is ringing, he simply sends a message: ‘G.’ Every question that follows remains unanswered.
Eventually, I surrendered to our entrenched culture of string-pulling. One well-placed request secured an almost immediate meeting.
The minister’s warmth and enthusiasm were inspiring. He promised financial support in the fiscal year beginning July 2026, performances at relevant Karachi Arts Council events, and free venues with full technical support for our provincial tour. He even invited our artistic director and choreographer Mohsin Babar and I to walk into his office whenever we wished, without an appointment.
Encouraged, I developed proposals for three major productions and submitted them electronically and by hand. Repeated follow-ups produced nothing but deafening silence. I managed to get his WhatsApp number and sent him messages. Again, nothing.
Still giving the minister the benefit of the doubt, I approached the secretary of culture and the director general of culture, assuming instructions had been passed down. Imagine my astonishment when my representative was told by both officers that the minister opposes dance performances and had forbidden the department from facilitating them because they were culturally inappropriate.
Which version were we to believe? The minister’s enthusiastic assurances or the instructions attributed to him by his senior officials?
More troubling was the apparent inability of those entrusted with promoting culture to distinguish serious artistic expression from vulgar entertainment. Dance is an ancient, sophisticated art form, deeply embedded in this region’s traditions. That a culture department should apparently regard it as inappropriate is an irony almost too painful to contemplate.
My bubble finally burst when I heard the minister declaring at press conferences his desire to promote Sindh’s ‘soft image’.
Why this obsession with manufacturing a soft image when the real image is waiting to be celebrated? Extraordinary artists across Sindh are creating, rehearsing and preserving centuries-old traditions. They need no manufactured image, merely recognition, respect and opportunities to perform. What better advertisement for Sindh’s culture than its own artists? And what greater irony than a department seeking to project cultural richness while obstructing those who embody it?
Elsewhere, culture departments and arts councils exist to serve artists, nurture and showcase their work. Here, the relationship seems reversed. Artists must cultivate connections, flatter officials and endure the indignity of waiting endlessly for meetings that may never materialise. Public servants become gatekeepers dispensing favours rather than facilitators fulfilling responsibilities.
Publicly supported arts council and culture department venues, especially those outside Karachi that frequently stand empty, demand exorbitant rentals from artists wishing to perform. What public purpose is served by pricing artists out of cultural spaces supposedly created for them?
And then there are the less-explicit obstacles. At one government auditorium in a small Sindh town, we were informed that there were no sweepers on the payroll and that arrangements would have to be made. One is left to decipher precisely what such statements imply, and what additional obligations might be expected before a public facility can actually be used.
The common thread running through these experiences is a bureaucracy that refuses to communicate clearly, apply transparent rules or take responsibility for its decisions. Silence is merely its most convenient instrument. An official who says no must explain why. An official who says nothing can avoid accountability indefinitely.
Why must citizens become supplicants simply to receive a response? Isn’t the Culture Department supposed to encourage artistic expression, support performers and make culture accessible? Shouldn’t officials welcome independent artists offering free performances to underserved communities?
Nobody is asking for personal favours. We are asking public servants to make public facilities available for a public purpose.
Perhaps there is simply no accountability for failing to respond. Whatever the explanation, opportunities disappear, artists lose heart and public infrastructure remains underutilised.
None of this demands sweeping reforms or enormous budgets. It requires officials to answer telephones, respond to correspondence, communicate decisions and remember whom their offices exist to serve.
And perhaps the greatest mystery is this: in a department dedicated to culture, why has silence become its most accomplished art form? ■
The writer is a rural development specialist and a patron of dance.
naween.a.mangi@gmail.com