Page 22 · Metro - Islamabad

AJK High Court extends orderly allowance to BS-20 officers across state

MUZAFFARABAD: The Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) High Court has extended the entitlement to orderly allowance to government officers in BS-20 and above serving across the state, declaring a government notification that restricted the benefit to officers posted at the headquarters in Muzaffarabad discriminatory.

Allowing 12 connected writ petitions, the single-member bench, comprising Justice Syed Shahid Bahar, set aside the Finance Department’s notification of July 27, 2020, and directed the government to extend the allowance to all eligible officers serving in connection with the affairs of the AJK government, irrespective of their place of posting.

In its judgment announced on Thursday, the senior puisne judge held that the exclusion of officers serving at other headquarters, including Mirpur, Rawalakot and Kotli, from a benefit available to their counterparts in Muzaffarabad had no reasonable basis and violated the fundamental right to equality guaranteed under Article 4(4)(15) of the AJK Interim Constitution, 1974.

The dispute originated from a government circular issued on Oct 22, 1977, which provided for orderly allowance to officers in BS-20 and above serving in the Civil Secretariat.

In a judgment on Dec 11, 2018, the High Court had already declared the arrangement discriminatory and directed the government to extend the allowance to all government officers in BS-20 and above at the headquarters, besides modifying the original circular accordingly.

However, the subsequent notification issued on July 27, 2020, confined the benefit to officers of BS-20 appointed on a regular basis and posted at the headquarters in Muzaffarabad.

This prompted officers serving in different departments and locations across AJK to approach the court, arguing that the notification had failed to implement the spirit of the 2018 judgment and perpetuated discrimination among government employees of the same grade.

The government opposed the petitions, contending that the allowance was admissible only to officers posted at the Muzaffarabad headquarters. It also argued that the petitioners were already receiving other allowances in view of their respective classifications and job descriptions, which were not admissible to Secretariat officers.

Rejecting this position, Justice Bahar observed that the petitioners could not be discriminated against merely because they were not serving in the Civil Secretariat or were posted outside the headquarters.

The judgment noted that officers working in other locations performed duties that were equally onerous, if not more demanding, than those performed by their counterparts in the Secretariat.

The court further held that there was no reasonable distinction between officers serving at the Muzaffarabad headquarters and those posted at other headquarters in the state to justify denying the latter the allowance.

In its operative order, the court set aside the July 27, 2020 notification and all other impugned notifications, circulars and orders through which the allowance had been withheld from the petitioners.

It directed the government to restore the orderly allowance of officers in BS-20 and above and issue a revised notification in accordance with the judgment.