Page 22 · Metro - Islamabad

Senate panel seeks rationale for shifting election appeals from SC to constitutional court

ISLAMABAD: The Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice has sought an explanation from the Ministry of Law and Justice and the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) over the proposed transfer of appeals under the Elections Act, 2017, from the Supreme Court to the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC).

The committee, chaired by Senator Farooq Hamid Naek, questioned the constitutional and legal basis for assigning appeals arising under the Elections Act to the FCC, asking the ministry and the ECP to explain the rationale behind supporting the proposed change.

The committee was examining the Elections (Amendment) Bill, 2026, a private member’s bill moved by Senator Khalil Tahir on his own behalf and on behalf of Senator Mohammad Abdul Qadir during the Senate sitting on Oct 26.

The proposed legislation seeks to bring the Elections Act, 2017, in line with the constitutional framework introduced through the Constitution (27th Amendment) Act, 2025.

During the deliberations, Senator Naek referred to sections 9 and 155 of the Elections Act and observed that appeals arising under these provisions were statutory in nature and distinct from appeals stemming from proceedings under Article 199 of the Constitution.

He questioned what constitutional provision or legal justification warranted transferring such appeals to the FCC, particularly when they originated under an ordinary statute rather than constitutional proceedings.

In view of the support extended by the Ministry of Law and Justice and the ECP to the proposed legislation, the committee chairman asked both institutions to explain the reasoning behind changing the existing appellate forum. He also sought clarification on the implications of the proposed amendment for the existing mechanism of hearing election-related appeals.

The issue assumes significance in the wake of the establishment of the Federal Constitutional Court under the 27th Constitutional Amendment, which introduced changes to the country’s constitutional judicial framework and distribution of judicial jurisdiction.

Meanwhile, the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs informed the committee that the National Assembly had already passed a separate private member’s bill dealing with the same subject.

The committee directed that a copy of the bill passed by the National Assembly, along with the report of its relevant standing committee, be presented before it at the next meeting for consideration.

The remaining agenda items were deferred until the next meeting.

Senators Shahadat Awan, Khalil Tahir and Mohammad Abdul Qadir attended the meeting.

The federal law minister and senior officials of the relevant departments were also present. — Malik Asad